Prohibit Conversion Therapy for A Minor · 5 peer-reviewed studies for, 2 against
Key takeaways
Large surveys of LGBTQ youth and young adults link exposure to conversion efforts with higher odds of suicide attempts, even after adjusting for other risk factors.
One study of transgender youth estimated higher rates of suicide attempts and running away after exposure, with the largest effects at ages 11 to 14.
Studies of adults also associate recalled conversion efforts with depression, PTSD symptoms, psychological distress and suicidal thoughts.
The evidence on harm is observational and cannot prove causation, but the associations are consistent across several large studies.
Studies cited against bans are older, small and self-selected, reporting perceived change without establishing effectiveness or safety for minors.
Stronger evidence: For
Verdict
On balance, the case for banning conversion therapy for minors is stronger. The most policy-relevant evidence focuses on harm: large contemporary surveys of LGBTQ youth and young adults find higher odds of suicide attempts among those reporting exposure to sexual orientation or gender identity conversion efforts, even after adjustment for other risk factors. While these studies are observational and cannot prove causality, the direction and magnitude of associations are concerning given minors’ heightened vulnerability, limited capacity for fully informed consent, and the power imbalance inherent in many “change effort” settings. The main counter-evidence often cited comes from older, small, and highly self-selected samples reporting perceived change or benefit. These studies do not establish effectiveness or safety for minors, and selection/measurement biases are substantial. Even if some adults seek counseling consistent with their values, minors are a distinct category: safeguarding standards typically justify tighter limits when potential irreversible harm and coercion risks are high. A well-crafted ban should narrowly target practices aiming to change orientation or gender identity, while allowing supportive, non-directive counseling (including for distress, family conflict, and identity exploration). That approach best aligns with evidence-weight, child protection norms, and clinical ethics.
Amy E. Green, Myeshia Price-Feeney et al. · 71 citations
A large U.S. survey of LGBTQ youth/young adults found higher odds of suicide attempts among those reporting exposure to sexual orientation or gender identity conversion efforts.
A small clinical report described individuals claiming change via religiously mediated processes, sometimes used to argue bans should not prohibit voluntary counseling aligned with personal beliefs.
Amy E. Green, Myeshia Price-Feeney et al. · 71 citations
A large U.S. survey of LGBTQ youth/young adults found higher odds of suicide attempts among those reporting exposure to sexual orientation or gender identity conversion efforts.
Study using 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey data found that exposure to conversion therapy increases the likelihood of suicide attempts by 55% and running away from home by 128% among transgender youth, with largest effects when exposure occurs at ages 11-14.
Comprehensive study finding that conversion therapy on LGBTQ youth and its associated harms cost an estimated $9.23 billion annually in the US, with documented links to depression, anxiety, suicide attempts, and substance abuse.
In a large U.S. sample of transgender adults, recalled exposure to gender identity conversion efforts was associated with greater psychological distress and increased odds of suicide attempts.
Cross-sectional study of 4,426 LGBTQ+ adults found that exposure to conversion therapy was significantly associated with increased symptoms of depression, PTSD, and suicidal ideation, particularly among transgender and gender-diverse individuals, supporting evidence for banning these practices.
A small clinical report described individuals claiming change via religiously mediated processes, sometimes used to argue bans should not prohibit voluntary counseling aligned with personal beliefs.
A self-selected sample reported perceived long-term shifts in orientation-related measures after change efforts, often cited to argue some individuals report benefit and should retain autonomy.
Frequently asked questions
Is conversion therapy harmful to young people?
Large surveys find that LGBTQ youth exposed to conversion efforts have higher odds of suicide attempts, along with links to depression, anxiety and substance abuse. These studies are observational, so they show strong associations rather than proof of cause.
Does conversion therapy work?
The studies cited in its favor come from small, self-selected samples of people reporting perceived change. They do not establish that it is effective or safe, especially for minors, and they carry substantial selection and measurement bias.
Why should minors be treated differently from adults?
Minors have heightened vulnerability, limited capacity for fully informed consent, and often face power imbalances in these settings. Child safeguarding standards typically justify tighter limits when risks of harm and coercion are high.
Would a ban stop minors from getting counseling about sexuality or gender?
A narrowly written ban would target only practices aimed at changing sexual orientation or gender identity. Supportive, non-directive counseling for distress, family conflict and identity exploration would remain allowed.