ClearFactAll topics

Should the U.S. deport illegal immigrants?

Deport illegal immigrant · 5 peer-reviewed studies for, 11 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: Against

Verdict

Across empirical studies, large-scale deportation and aggressive interior enforcement appear to impose substantial costs on U.S. citizens and permanent residents while delivering, at best, modest and largely theoretical gains. Structural and simulation models show that immigration can lower wages for some low-skill natives or reduce welfare under particular labor-market and policy assumptions, and these results are often invoked to justify mass removal of unauthorized workers. However, they do not directly evaluate real-world deportation campaigns and typically abstract from general-equilibrium feedbacks on local demand, informality, and long-run human capital.

By contrast, quasi-experimental evidence from enforcement programs such as Secure Communities and early ICE interventions shows that tougher deportation-oriented policies weaken local labor markets, reduce employment and earnings for U.S.-born workers, and increase poverty among citizen children. Other work links heightened enforcement and parental removals to worse birth outcomes and significant psychological distress for U.S.-citizen children, with likely long-term consequences for health and productivity. Taken together, the best-identified evidence suggests that broad deportation strategies are more likely to damage economic opportunity and well-being for citizens and mixed-status families than to deliver clear net benefits. Targeted enforcement focused on serious crime, combined with legal status reforms and labor protections, better aligns with the observed data than blanket deportation of unauthorized immigrants.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Immigration can depress wages of competing low-skill natives (Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2003)

1,600 citations

Using a national skill-cell approach, Borjas finds that immigration flows, which include large numbers of unauthorized workers in low-skill groups, reduce wages of directly competing natives: a 10% increase in labor supply is associated with roughly a 3–4% wage decline for that skill group. Proponents of stricter enforcement and deportation cite this as evidence that reducing unauthorized immigration could relieve wage pressure on the least-educated native workers, though the study does not model deportation policies directly.

Strongest study against

Immigration Enforcement Policies and the Mental Health of US-Citizens: Findings from a Comparative Analysis (American Journal of Community Psychology, 2020)

Miguel Pinedo and Carmen R. Valdez · 150 citations

Study demonstrates that knowing a migrant who had been detained or deported was associated with two-fold odds of reporting mental health problems in the past 12 months, indicating significant cumulative mental health effects of immigration enforcement practices on US citizens, particularly Latinx populations.

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (5)

Immigration can depress wages of competing low-skill natives (Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2003)

1,600 citations

Using a national skill-cell approach, Borjas finds that immigration flows, which include large numbers of unauthorized workers in low-skill groups, reduce wages of directly competing natives: a 10% increase in labor supply is associated with roughly a 3–4% wage decline for that skill group. Proponents of stricter enforcement and deportation cite this as evidence that reducing unauthorized immigration could relieve wage pressure on the least-educated native workers, though the study does not model deportation policies directly.

Illegal immigration may impose welfare costs in open-economy models (Journal of International Economics, 1987)

200 citations

Bond develops an early open-economy trade model showing that illegal immigration can, under certain structural and policy conditions, reduce host-country welfare by distorting factor prices and interacting with pre-existing trade or tax distortions. Although not U.S.-specific and highly stylized, the paper underpins a strand of theoretical work suggesting that large unauthorized inflows may create welfare losses that, in principle, could be mitigated by reducing the stock of unauthorized migrants through stricter enforcement or deportations.

Illegal immigration may lower native welfare under some policy regimes (Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 2010)

140 citations

Liu builds a dynamic general equilibrium model with search frictions to study illegal immigration and shows that, depending on labor-market institutions and fiscal policy, unauthorized inflows can reduce native welfare. In scenarios with binding labor-market frictions or limited tax capacity, reducing illegal immigration can raise per-capita consumption and welfare for natives. Although highly stylized and not U.S.-episode specific, the model is often cited by advocates who argue that tighter enforcement and deportations can improve long-run macroeconomic outcomes for citizens.

Illegal immigration can generate welfare losses with binding minimum wages (Journal of Population Economics, 2009)

90 citations

Palivos analyzes illegal immigration in a dynamic growth model and finds that, while illegal immigration can raise host-country welfare in a frictionless economy, the introduction of a binding minimum wage reverses the result: immigration then increases unemployment and can decrease consumption and welfare for domestic low-skill workers. This theoretic result is used by some proponents of deportation to argue that, in highly regulated low-wage labor markets, limiting unauthorized workers through stricter enforcement could protect vulnerable native workers’ employment and welfare.

Against (11)

Immigration Enforcement Policies and the Mental Health of US-Citizens: Findings from a Comparative Analysis (American Journal of Community Psychology, 2020)

Miguel Pinedo and Carmen R. Valdez · 150 citations

Study demonstrates that knowing a migrant who had been detained or deported was associated with two-fold odds of reporting mental health problems in the past 12 months, indicating significant cumulative mental health effects of immigration enforcement practices on US citizens, particularly Latinx populations.

The Distress of Citizen-Children with Detained and Deported Parents ( Journal of Child and Family Studies , 2015)

Luis H. Zayas, Sergio Aguilar-Gaxiola et al. · 141 citations

Zayas and coauthors document high levels of anxiety, depression, and behavioral problems among U.S.-citizen children whose parents have been detained or deported. The study highlights how immigration enforcement and family separation associated with deportations can create long-lasting psychological harm and developmental risks for citizen children, raising ethical and social-policy concerns about large-scale removal strategies.

Immigration enforcement increases poverty risk among citizen children (Journal of Public Economics, 2018)

130 citations

Amuedo-Dorantes, Arenas-Arroyo, and Sevilla construct an index of interior immigration enforcement and show that tougher policies, including 287(g)-style cooperation that facilitates deportations, increase the likelihood that households with U.S.-born children and likely unauthorized parents live in poverty and experience large income losses. The authors conclude that ramped-up enforcement has sizable negative spillovers on citizen children, undermining their economic security and long-run opportunities.

Heightened immigration enforcement harms U.S. citizens’ birth outcomes (PLOS ONE, 2021)

Romina Tome, Marcos A. Rangel et al. · 40 citations

Tome and coauthors analyze early ICE interventions and heightened immigration enforcement in North Carolina and find that citizen infants born in counties exposed to aggressive enforcement have worse birth outcomes, including lower birth weight. The study links deportation-oriented enforcement to increased maternal stress and reduced prenatal care, implying that large-scale deportations can damage the health of U.S.-citizen newborns who are not themselves targets of immigration policy.

Local immigration enforcement worsens health and mental health (International Migration Review, 2019)

Julia Shu-Huah Wang and Neeraj Kaushal · 40 citations

Wang and Kaushal exploit variation in adoption of local immigration enforcement agreements and find that heightened enforcement is associated with worse self-reported health and more mental health problems among likely undocumented immigrants and their communities. The chilling effects on service use and increased stress exposure suggest that deportation-oriented policies can generate substantial public-health externalities extending beyond the non-citizen population.

Immigration enforcement reduces employment and earnings of U.S.-born workers (Journal of Labor Economics, 2023)

30 citations

East and coauthors study the Secure Communities program, a major interior enforcement initiative, and find that ramped-up deportation risk reduces employment and earnings not only for non-citizens but also for U.S.-born workers in affected areas. Their estimates imply that harsh enforcement weakens local labor markets and overall labor demand rather than “freeing” jobs for natives, suggesting that large-scale deportations would likely impose broad economic costs on citizens.

Raids, Fear, and Forgone Care: ICE Enforcement-Driven Healthcare Avoidance and Behavioral Withdrawal in Los Angeles County, 2024–2025 (Research Square, 2025)

A longitudinal study of 1,182 LABarometer Survey respondents found that ICE enforcement exposure caused Hispanic residents to be over 3 times more likely to avoid medical care in 2025 compared to 2024 (32.3% vs 9.5%), demonstrating that immigration enforcement serves as a structural determinant of health creating new healthcare barriers independent of citizenship status.

Frequently asked questions

Does deporting illegal immigrants raise wages for American workers?

One national study found that a 10% increase in labor supply was associated with roughly a 3–4% wage decline for competing low-skill natives, but it did not model deportation directly. Studies of actual enforcement programs, including Secure Communities and the 1930s Mexican repatriations, found reduced employment and earnings for U.S.-born workers instead.

How does deportation affect U.S.-citizen children?

Research links parental detention and deportation to anxiety, depression and behavioral problems in citizen children. Tougher enforcement is also associated with higher poverty risk for households with U.S.-born children and with lower birth weight among citizen infants in areas with aggressive enforcement.

Is there an ethical argument in favor of deportation?

One political theory paper argues that if states have the right to restrict immigration, they also have a right to enforce those restrictions, including through deportation. The author uses an analogy with tax law enforcement to set a moral baseline.

What immigration enforcement approach does the evidence support?

Across the studies reviewed, the data align better with targeted enforcement focused on serious crime, combined with legal status reforms and labor protections, than with blanket deportation of unauthorized immigrants.

Related questions