Does chronic digital multitasking reduce working memory capacity and cognitive control abilities?
5 peer-reviewed studies for, 5 against
Key takeaways
The evidence does not show that chronic digital multitasking reduces working memory capacity or cognitive control.
Some studies found heavy media multitaskers were more distractible, worse at task switching, and had more attention lapses and poorer memory.
Replications and meta-analyses found the link is small and inconsistent, and one meta-analysis found it vanished after correcting for small-study bias.
Some studies found no working memory difference, and one found heavy multitaskers were better at task switching.
All the studies are correlational, so none shows multitasking causes these differences; traits like impulsiveness may lead people to multitask.
Stronger evidence: Against
Verdict
The evidence does not show that chronic digital multitasking reduces working memory capacity or cognitive control. On the "for" side, Ophir, Nass and Wagner (PNAS, 2009) found heavy media multitaskers were more distractible and worse at switching tasks, Uncapher et al. (Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 2016) found poorer working and long-term memory, Moisala et al. (NeuroImage, 2016) linked heavy multitasking to greater distractibility and extra prefrontal effort, and Madore et al. (Nature, 2020) tied it to more attention lapses and forgetting. Uncapher and Wagner (PNAS, 2018) concluded the balance of evidence points to poorer performance in heavy multitaskers. On the "against" side, these findings have not held up consistently. Wiradhany and Nieuwenstein (Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics, 2017) failed to replicate most of the original effects, and their meta-analysis found the link disappeared after correcting for small-study bias. Parry and le Roux (Cyberpsychology, 2021) found only a small overall association across 118 assessments, Wiradhany et al. (2020) found no effect in 261 people, Minear et al. (2013) found no working memory difference, and Alzahabi and Becker (2013) found heavy multitaskers were actually better at task switching. Most importantly, every study is correlational: none shows that multitasking causes the differences, and Minear et al. suggest pre-existing traits such as impulsiveness may lead people to multitask. On balance the "against" side is stronger: any association is small and inconsistent, and there is no evidence that multitasking reduces these abilities. Multitasking can still hurt performance in the moment, and the link with attention lapses deserves further study.
The landmark Stanford study comparing heavy and light media multitaskers on standard cognitive control tests. Heavy multitaskers were more easily distracted by irrelevant information in their surroundings and in memory, and surprisingly performed worse at switching between tasks, likely because they were less able to filter out the task they were not doing. The authors conclude heavy media multitasking is associated with a distinct, less selective way of processing information.
Two well-powered replications of the 2009 Stanford study ran 14 tests; only five showed heavier multitaskers were more distractible, and only two held up under a stricter Bayesian analysis. A meta-analysis of 39 effect sizes found a weak association that became non-significant after correcting for small-study bias, leading the authors to question whether the link exists at all.
The landmark Stanford study comparing heavy and light media multitaskers on standard cognitive control tests. Heavy multitaskers were more easily distracted by irrelevant information in their surroundings and in memory, and surprisingly performed worse at switching between tasks, likely because they were less able to filter out the task they were not doing. The authors conclude heavy media multitasking is associated with a distinct, less selective way of processing information.
Heavy media multitaskers performed worse than light multitaskers on a working memory task and on a later long-term memory test, whether or not distracting items were present. The authors suggest the deficits reflect broader differences in attention, such as more frequent attention lapses, rather than only greater sensitivity to distraction.
Using brain recordings and pupil measurements in young adults, the study found that lapses of attention just before trying to remember something predicted later forgetting. People who reported heavier media multitasking showed more attention lapses and poorer memory, linking everyday multitasking habits to the attention failures that undermine working and long-term memory.
In a brain imaging study of adolescents and young adults, those who media multitasked more performed worse on attention tasks when distractors were present and showed greater activity in the right prefrontal cortex, suggesting they needed more mental effort to stay focused. The authors interpret this as evidence that heavy media multitasking is linked to greater distractibility.
Reviewing a decade of research, the authors conclude that the balance of evidence suggests heavier media multitaskers perform worse in a number of cognitive domains, particularly on tasks requiring sustained, goal-directed attention, although many studies find no difference. They note the direction of causality is still unknown and call for research on whether the effects are real and remediable.
Two well-powered replications of the 2009 Stanford study ran 14 tests; only five showed heavier multitaskers were more distractible, and only two held up under a stricter Bayesian analysis. A meta-analysis of 39 effect sizes found a weak association that became non-significant after correcting for small-study bias, leading the authors to question whether the link exists at all.
A meta-analysis of 118 assessments found the overall association between media multitasking and cognitive control was small and varied with how multitasking and cognition were measured. The authors conclude that, ten years after the original study, researchers are no closer to understanding the relationship, and that causality and mechanisms remain unestablished.
Heavy and light media multitaskers did not differ in working memory capacity or in several attention and task-switching measures. Heavy multitaskers did score somewhat lower on a test of fluid intelligence and reported more impulsiveness, suggesting personal traits may lead people to multitask rather than multitasking reducing working memory.
Across two experiments, heavy and light media multitaskers performed equally when doing two tasks at once, and heavy multitaskers were actually better at switching between tasks. This contradicts the idea that chronic multitasking impairs cognitive control, and suggests it may even be associated with more flexible task switching.
In a study of 261 people, those who media multitasked more did not perform worse on a working memory task as the number of distractors increased, did not perform worse overall, and did not report more attention lapses during the task. The results held across several statistical methods, and the authors call for better-powered studies with more precise measures of multitasking.
The debate
Hannah: Constant multitasking with phones, laptops and TV seems to change how our minds work. The famous Stanford study by Ophir, Nass and Wagner found heavy media multitaskers were more easily distracted and, surprisingly, worse at switching between tasks.
Ryan: It's famous, but it hasn't replicated well. Wiradhany and Nieuwenstein ran two well-powered replications with 14 tests, and only two effects survived a strict analysis. Their meta-analysis found the link vanished after correcting for small-study bias.
Hannah: The same Stanford group found more. Uncapher and colleagues showed heavy multitaskers had worse working memory and long-term memory. And their 2020 Nature study found heavy multitaskers had more attention lapses, which predicted forgetting.
Ryan: Notice those are all correlations. Minear and colleagues found no working memory difference at all, but heavy multitaskers were more impulsive. Maybe impulsive people multitask, rather than multitasking damaging memory.
Hannah: Brain imaging suggests something is going on, though. Moisala's team found heavy multitaskers needed more prefrontal activity to resist distraction, and still did worse.
Ryan: And Alzahabi and Becker found the opposite on task switching: heavy multitaskers were better at it. Wiradhany's later study of 261 people found no extra distractibility and no extra mind-wandering.
Hannah: Even Uncapher and Wagner's review admits many studies find nothing. But they say the balance of evidence points to worse sustained attention.
Ryan: Parry and le Roux pooled 118 assessments and found only a small association that depended on how it was measured. Ten years on, they say we're no closer to understanding it.
Hannah: So the link with attention is worth watching, but it isn't proven to shrink working memory.
Ryan: Agreed. Multitasking hurts performance in the moment, but there's no solid evidence it permanently reduces these abilities.
Frequently asked questions
Does media multitasking damage your brain?
The available studies do not show that multitasking causes lasting harm to working memory or cognitive control. Some brain imaging work found heavy multitaskers used more prefrontal effort to stay focused, but these findings are correlational.
Are heavy multitaskers worse at switching between tasks?
The results conflict. One well-known study found heavy multitaskers were worse at task switching, while another found they were actually better at it, and other studies found no difference.
Why do some studies link multitasking to poorer memory?
Some research suggests heavy multitaskers have more frequent attention lapses, which can lead to forgetting. However, larger studies and meta-analyses have not consistently confirmed this association, and the link with attention lapses deserves further study.
Is multitasking still bad for performance?
Multitasking can still hurt performance in the moment. The open question is whether habitual multitasking reduces cognitive abilities over time, and current evidence does not show that it does.