The Hill/Emerson College Polling - Sep 2026
El Sayed polling: 48%
All topics✅ El Sayed won · El Sayed 52.5%, Rogers 45.5%
Source · unofficial results
The most relevant evidence is head-to-head polling, and it modestly favors El-Sayed. The RealClearPolitics average for 9/24 to 10/14 has him at 48% to Rogers's 46%. The Hill/Emerson poll from September shows the same 48-46 split, and the headline on the NYT/Siena report says El-Sayed leads. The one contrary data point is the August Fox News poll, which had Rogers ahead 51% to 47%. It is the oldest of the three and was taken right after the primary. The direction since then favors El-Sayed, though a two-point edge is within normal polling error. Many entries listing 0% for both candidates, including Marist, InsiderAdvantage and several averages, look like missing or unparsed data, so I give them no weight. The same applies to El-Sayed's 0 Wikipedia page views, which likely reflects a bad page link. Rogers's page views therefore can't be compared with his.
Google Trends shows El-Sayed's search interest rising from 4 to 5 to 7 over August to October, above Rogers's 1 to 2 to 3. That suggests more attention, but not necessarily more votes.
Rogers has real strengths. He was an FBI agent, won seven House terms in a swing district, chaired the House Intelligence Committee, and lost the 2024 Senate race by only 1.5 points. These give him name recognition and credibility with swing voters. But they describe a candidate who has already lost a statewide race, and they don't outweigh current polling.
El-Sayed won a hard primary against Haley Stevens despite more than $30M in outside spending against him. He also has statewide campaign experience from 2018 and a public-health record. The seat is open in a swing state in a midterm that favors the party out of the White House, which gives the Democratic nominee a structural edge.
Overall, El-Sayed has a slight advantage based on the latest polls and the political environment. The margin is narrow and the race remains competitive, but the evidence favors him.
El Sayed polling: 48%
El Sayed polling: 48%
El Sayed polling: 47%
El Sayed polling: 0%
El Sayed polling: 0%
El Sayed polling: 0%
El Sayed polling: 0%
El Sayed polling: 0%
El Sayed polling: 0%
3-month average US search interest for El Sayed: 7/100
3-month average US search interest for El Sayed: 5/100
3-month average US search interest for El Sayed: 4/100
30-day page views for El Sayed: 0
30-day page views for El Sayed: 0
30-day page views for El Sayed: 0
Abdul El-Sayed is a physician who led the Detroit Health Department and later Wayne County's health and human services department, and finished second to Gretchen Whitmer in the 2018 Democratic gubernatorial primary — giving him statewide campaign experience and a public-health record.
El-Sayed won the Democratic Senate primary by about a point over U.S. Rep. Haley Stevens, overcoming a reported $30M+ AIPAC-led effort against him. A progressive backed by Bernie Sanders, he would be the first Muslim U.S. senator if elected.
With Sen. Gary Peters retiring and midterms favoring the party out of the White House, Michigan is a genuine battleground where the Democratic nominee starts even or slightly ahead in the open-seat contest.
Mike Rogers polling: 51%
Mike Rogers polling: 46%
Mike Rogers polling: 46%
Mike Rogers polling: 0%
Mike Rogers polling: 0%
Mike Rogers polling: 0%
Mike Rogers polling: 0%
Mike Rogers polling: 0%
Mike Rogers polling: 0%
3-month average US search interest for Mike Rogers: 3/100
3-month average US search interest for Mike Rogers: 2/100
3-month average US search interest for Mike Rogers: 1/100
30-day page views for Mike Rogers: 1,008
30-day page views for Mike Rogers: 934
30-day page views for Mike Rogers: 579
Rogers served as chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, overseeing U.S. intelligence agencies and leading bipartisan efforts on cybersecurity and counterterrorism.
Rogers ran a competitive 2024 Senate campaign, losing to Elissa Slotkin by just 1.5 percentage points while building statewide name recognition and donor networks.
Before entering politics, Rogers served as an FBI special agent, giving him credibility on law enforcement and public safety issues that resonate with swing voters.
Rogers won seven consecutive elections in Michigan's 8th congressional district, a swing district that included Lansing and its suburbs, proving his ability to win moderate voters.
Lisa: El-Sayed beat a well-funded congresswoman while AIPAC spent thirty million against him. That's a candidate with a real base and statewide experience from 2018.
James: He also just came through a divisive primary that split the party, and he's untested with general-election swing voters. Rogers nearly won this seat in 2024 — losing by a fraction of a point.
Lisa: 2024 was a presidential year; a midterm with a Republican in the White House is friendlier terrain for the Democrat, and Michigan leans blue at the top of the ticket.
James: It leans blue narrowly, and Rogers is exactly the kind of proven statewide Republican who can capitalize if El-Sayed struggles to unify moderates.
Lisa: Fair — I'd call it a toss-up. You give Rogers the slight edge; I'd put it even. Either way, re-derive when polling lands.