Ranked by citation count.
The debate
Mark: David, we can't just dismiss concerns about election integrity as "conspiracy theories." There is peer-reviewed research, like the 2014 Richman study in Electoral Studies, suggesting that non-citizen voting could be significant enough to flip Senate seats or even the presidency. If the system has holes, they'll be exploited.
David: Mark, that same journal published a devastating rebuttal just a year later. The "non-citizens" in that study were mostly citizens who accidentally checked the wrong box on a survey. When you account for that simple measurement error, the evidence for non-citizen voting virtually disappears. We’re talking about an infinitesimal fraction of the electorate.
Mark: But it's not just survey data. John Lott's 2022 study in Public Choice pointed to statistically significant anomalies in the 2020 election results in Georgia and Pennsylvania. He argued that the shifts in vote totals didn't align with traditional voting patterns and could only be explained by irregularities. Why is it "irresponsible" to look at the math?
David: Because the "math" often ignores context. Those shifts are better explained by changes in voting methods, like the surge in mail-in ballots during the pandemic, and shifts in demographic leanings. Every time these claims are brought to court or subjected to a hand recount—like we saw in Arizona and Georgia—the results come back the same. If there was a massive fraud machine, it would leave a paper trail, but we only find clerical errors.
Mark: A "clerical error" is exactly what people worry about when they see names of dead people on voter rolls or people registered in two states. Even the study in the American Political Science Review admitted that double voting happens. If we don't have strict ID laws and clean rolls, we're inviting trouble.
David: The study you’re referencing, the 2020 Goel paper, actually found that for every double vote prevented by purging rolls, you’d likely disenfranchise 300 legitimate voters. The "fraud" people panic about is almost always a guy named John Smith being confused with a different John Smith. When we actually investigate, we find that the threat of fraud is tiny compared to the threat of making it harder for citizens to vote.
Mark: I'm not saying we should block voters, I'm saying we need a system that people can trust. When half the country doubts the results, that’s a crisis of legitimacy. Significant or not, if the vulnerabilities are there, the public perception will remain negative.
David: The crisis of legitimacy isn't caused by the system; it’s caused by the rhetoric. The empirical evidence is clear: U.S. elections are among the most scrutinized and secure in the world. Fraud is rare, localized, and ultimately insignificant to the final tally.
Mark: I hope you're right, David, but as tech advances, the risks only grow. We need to be vigilant.
David: Vigilance is good. Misinformation isn't. Let’s stick to the data.
Frequently asked questions
Did voter fraud change the outcome of the 2020 presidential election?
The weight of peer-reviewed evidence says no. A 2021 review found that widely circulated statistical claims of fraud were not credible, and audits and hand recounts confirmed machine counts. One 2022 study reported anomalies in Georgia and Pennsylvania that it said were consistent with fraud.
Do non-citizens vote in U.S. elections in large numbers?
A 2014 study using survey data argued non-citizen voting could affect Electoral College and congressional races. A 2015 rebuttal showed those findings were statistically indistinguishable from measurement error, such as respondents giving incorrect citizenship information.
Does mail-in voting lead to election fraud?
A study of three states from 1996 to 2018 found that universal vote-by-mail did not change either party's turnout share or vote share. The authors read this as evidence that mail voting does not create meaningful opportunities for fraud to alter outcomes.
Why do so many Americans believe election fraud is common?
A 2024 survey of 2,211 registered voters found that partisanship and conspiratorial thinking strongly predicted fraud beliefs, rather than actual evidence. Another 2024 study found that voters who see their state's security policies as effective believe there is less fraud and feel more confident in elections.