Is remote or hybrid work good for employees and productivity?
Remote/hybrid work · 6 peer-reviewed studies for, 5 against
Key takeaways
Randomized experiments find hybrid work can improve job satisfaction and reduce quit rates without lowering performance ratings.
A call center experiment found working from home raised performance and cut attrition, though promotion rates fell for home workers.
Studies of office workers link hybrid and remote work to less mental distress, burnout and psychological strain, especially when the arrangement is self-chosen.
Firm-wide remote work has been linked to more siloed collaboration, fewer cross-team ties and weaker knowledge spillovers between peers.
Remote collaboration and videoconferencing are associated with fewer creative and breakthrough ideas, which matters most for innovation-heavy work.
Stronger evidence: For
Verdict
The best evidence suggests remote/hybrid work can deliver real benefits, but not uniformly across tasks. Randomized experiments show that working from home or in a hybrid schedule can improve retention and job satisfaction, and in some settings can maintain or even raise measured productivity. These gains likely come from reduced commuting, better scheduling, and improved focus for certain kinds of individual work. However, credible organizational data also shows important downsides: firm-wide remote work can make collaboration networks more siloed and reduce cross-team connections, and large-scale studies link remote collaboration to fewer breakthrough (disruptive) ideas. Evidence from the U.S. Patent Office further suggests weaker peer effects and knowledge spillovers when employees telecommute, which matters most for learning-intensive and innovation-heavy work. Overall, the evidence weight favors adopting hybrid/remote as a flexible default for roles with substantial independent work and clear performance metrics, while intentionally protecting collaboration and innovation through structured in-person time, onboarding, mentorship, and cross-team interaction. Because high-quality experimental evidence shows substantial retention benefits without performance harm in at least some skilled settings, the stronger side is for remote/hybrid work—implemented thoughtfully rather than as a one-size-fits-all mandate.
Prithwiraj Choudhury, Christos A. Makridis et al. · 50 citations
A randomized field experiment with 148 professional employees at BRAC in Bangladesh found that intermediate hybrid work (approximately 2 days per week in office) improved job satisfaction, work-life balance, and reduced isolation without harming employee performance as rated by managers.
Melanie S. Brucks and Jonathan Levav · 600 citations
Laboratory study and field experiment across five countries showing that videoconferencing inhibits the production of creative ideas. However, videoconferencing groups are equally effective at selecting which ideas to pursue.
Prithwiraj Choudhury, Christos A. Makridis et al. · 50 citations
A randomized field experiment with 148 professional employees at BRAC in Bangladesh found that intermediate hybrid work (approximately 2 days per week in office) improved job satisfaction, work-life balance, and reduced isolation without harming employee performance as rated by managers.
A randomized experiment in a large Chinese call center found working from home increased performance and reduced attrition, though promotion rates fell for home workers.
Lorena Edith Trevino Garcia and Jan Olav Christensen
Large-scale study of 24,763 Norwegian office workers found that employees practicing flexible hybrid work-from-home arrangements were less likely to report mental distress compared to those with no WFH options, particularly when work-from-home was self-chosen. This provides evidence that hybrid work flexibility can benefit employee mental health and work-life balance.
A longitudinal study of 494 Polish workers (206 remote, 288 stationary) conducted in 2021-2022 found that remote workers experienced better mental well-being over time, with significantly lower levels of psychological strain, depression, and burnout compared to on-site workers. The study demonstrates that some psychosocial working conditions were also assessed more favorably by remote workers.
This study examines the burnout-reducing potential of remote and hybrid work arrangements. It identifies work autonomy as a key mediating factor in how flexible work arrangements affect employee burnout and well-being, providing evidence that hybrid work can positively impact employee mental health outcomes.
Melanie S. Brucks and Jonathan Levav · 600 citations
Laboratory study and field experiment across five countries showing that videoconferencing inhibits the production of creative ideas. However, videoconferencing groups are equally effective at selecting which ideas to pursue.
Using Microsoft internal communication/collaboration data, finds firm-wide remote work made collaboration networks more siloed with fewer cross-group ties.
Yiling Lin, Carl Benedikt Frey et al. · 127 citations
Large-scale analysis of papers and patents finds remote collaboration is associated with less disruptive, more incremental innovation compared with on-site collaboration.
Michael D. Frakes and Melissa F. Wasserman · 19 citations
Finds examiner peer influences and knowledge flows are stronger when working on-site than when telecommuting, suggesting reduced learning spillovers under remote work.
Large-scale study of 48,000+ IT employees found hybrid and remote work reduced innovation quality and quantity. Hybrid work impaired innovation particularly when teams lacked coordination on office vs. home days due to increased collaboration costs.
Frequently asked questions
Does working from home make employees less productive?
Not necessarily. Randomized experiments found hybrid work did not harm performance evaluations, and one call center study found home workers performed better. Results depend on the type of work.
Is hybrid work better for mental health?
Several studies link hybrid and remote work to lower mental distress, burnout and depression compared with fully on-site work. Work autonomy and choosing to work from home appear to play a role in these benefits.
Does remote work hurt innovation and collaboration?
Evidence suggests it can. Studies found remote work made collaboration networks more siloed, reduced knowledge flows between colleagues, and was associated with fewer creative and breakthrough ideas.
What is the best way to set up hybrid work?
The evidence favors hybrid or remote work for roles with substantial independent work and clear performance metrics, paired with structured in-person time for collaboration, onboarding, mentorship and cross-team interaction. One study found hybrid work hurt innovation most when teams did not coordinate their office days.