ClearFactAll topics

Should euthanasia be legal?

5 peer-reviewed studies for, 4 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: For

Verdict

Across jurisdictions, the strongest empirical case for legalization is that assisted dying can be implemented as a regulated, relatively rare end-of-life option without clear evidence of widespread abuse. Large reviews and population studies from places where euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide is legal describe low overall incidence, extensive procedural requirements, and patterns concentrated among patients with serious illness—suggesting a legal framework can channel requests into monitored medical processes rather than covert or violent alternatives. Legalization also advances autonomy for competent adults facing intolerable suffering, and can coexist with palliative care expansion.\n\nThe strongest objections are not hypothetical. Evidence indicates legalization does not reliably reduce non-assisted suicide rates and may increase overall self-initiated deaths in some contexts, raising public-health and cultural concerns. Safeguards are also harder when eligibility expands beyond terminal illness; psychiatric cases illustrate difficulties judging irremediability, capacity, and undue influence. \n\nNetting these together, the evidence supports legalization only with tight eligibility, robust capacity assessments, mandatory reporting, independent review, and strong palliative and mental-health services. With those constraints, the balance of evidence favors legalizing a carefully limited form of assisted dying.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Strongest study against

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (5)

Against (4)

Identifying practical clinical problems in active euthanasia: A systematic literature review of the findings in countries where euthanasia is legal (Palliative & Supportive Care, 2023)

Madoka Kono, Nana Arai et al.

Systematic review of 140 studies examining euthanasia implementation in countries where it's legal. Identified 5 major clinical problems including ambiguous eligibility criteria creating "slippery slope" risks, insufficient guarantees of patient voluntariness, difficulty distinguishing psychological from physical suffering, noncompliance by medical professionals, and unequal burden on physicians.

Frequently asked questions

Is euthanasia common where it is legal?

Reviews of jurisdictions in the United States, Canada and Europe describe euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide as relatively rare. Cases tend to be concentrated among patients with serious illness.

Does legalizing euthanasia lead to a slippery slope?

The evidence is mixed. A large analysis of Belgian cases found psychiatric and cognitive cases stayed stable and increases were mostly due to demographic change, while a systematic review of 140 studies flagged ambiguous eligibility criteria and weak voluntariness guarantees as slippery-slope risks.

Does legal assisted dying reduce other suicides?

A systematic review found that legalization does not reduce non-assisted suicide rates. It may also increase overall self-initiated deaths in some subgroups.

Are there medical complications with euthanasia or assisted suicide?

A study of 649 Dutch cases found complications in 7% of assisted suicides and problems with completion in 16%, sometimes requiring physicians to give a lethal injection. Problems were more frequent with assisted suicide than with euthanasia.

Related questions