ClearFactAll topics

Should transgender athletes be allowed to compete in sports?

Transgender Athlete Participation in Sport · 9 peer-reviewed studies for, 2 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: For

Verdict

Evidence on transgender athlete participation is still thin—especially for elite, sport-specific outcomes—but the best syntheses increasingly suggest that after sustained gender-affirming hormone therapy, many key fitness measures in transgender women converge toward cisgender female ranges. Systematic reviews and a recent meta-analysis report reductions in lean mass/strength and haemoglobin (relevant to endurance), with physical fitness often comparable to cisgender women on several measures, while emphasizing substantial data gaps (few athletes, limited longitudinal follow-up, and heterogeneity by sport and testing methods). At the same time, other reviews and some large retrospective datasets indicate that for certain performance domains—particularly those tied to muscle size and power—residual advantages from prior male puberty may persist beyond commonly used eligibility windows, implying that a one-size-fits-all rule may not ensure competitive equity in every event. Overall, the weight of evidence supports allowing participation with sport-specific eligibility criteria that track relevant performance determinants (and update as better data emerge), rather than blanket exclusions or blanket assumptions of advantage.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Strength, Power and Aerobic Capacity of Transgender Athletes: A Cross-Sectional Study (British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2024)

Blair Hamilton, Andrew Brown et al. · 86 citations

Cross-sectional laboratory study of 23 transgender women, 21 cisgender women, and cisgender men athletes found transgender women had similar handgrip strength, lower-body power, and aerobic capacity to cisgender women, suggesting performance variation depends on specific sport and physiological measures rather than categorical differences.

Strongest study against

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (9)

Strength, Power and Aerobic Capacity of Transgender Athletes: A Cross-Sectional Study (British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2024)

Blair Hamilton, Andrew Brown et al. · 86 citations

Cross-sectional laboratory study of 23 transgender women, 21 cisgender women, and cisgender men athletes found transgender women had similar handgrip strength, lower-body power, and aerobic capacity to cisgender women, suggesting performance variation depends on specific sport and physiological measures rather than categorical differences.

How does hormone transition in transgender women change body composition, muscle strength and haemoglobin? Systematic review with a focus on the implications for sport participation (British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2021)

Joanna Harper, Emma O'Donnell et al.

Systematic review finding that hormone therapy reduces strength/lean mass and rapidly lowers haemoglobin toward cisgender female ranges, supporting sport-specific, evidence-based inclusion policies while acknowledging remaining uncertainties.

Physical Fitness and Exercise Performance of Transgender Women (Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2025)

ATHIWAT SAITONG, WITTHAWAT NAEOWONG et al.

Cross-sectional study comparing physical fitness measures of transgender women (n=30) on long-term feminizing hormone therapy (8-10 years) with reference cisgender women and men. Found transgender women demonstrated similar levels of physical fitness to cisgender women, with significantly lower performance than cisgender men across measures including muscular strength, anaerobic power, and aerobic capacity.

Transgender women and competitive sports: Considerations from Endocrinology (Endocrinología, Diabetes y Nutrición, 2025)

Laura Cuadrado Clemente, María Miguélez González et al.

Comprehensive endocrinology literature review examining gender-affirming hormone therapy's impact on athletic performance. Found significant decreases in hematocrit, total serum testosterone, lean body mass, strength, and muscle area after 12 months of GAHT, with increases in fat mass, supporting inclusion policies with appropriate hormone suppression criteria.

Longitudinal Performance Changes in Transgender Women Athletes Pre and Post Gender Affirming Hormone Therapy (European Journal of Sport Science, 2025)

Joanna Harper, Richard C. Blagrove et al.

This study evaluated athletic performance in 9 transgender women runners and 1 swimmer using both retrospective and prospective data. Results showed that average race times for runners increased by 14.6% after ~31 months of GAHT, with performance adjustments accounting for training differences. The findings suggest that event demands and exercise training significantly affect the impact of hormone therapy on athletic performance.

Against (2)

Frequently asked questions

Do transgender women have an athletic advantage over cisgender women?

It depends on the measure and the sport. Several studies found transgender women on hormone therapy had fitness comparable to cisgender women, while other reviews suggest some advantages in muscle size and power may persist for certain periods.

How does hormone therapy affect athletic performance in transgender women?

Reviews report that gender-affirming hormone therapy reduces testosterone, haemoglobin, lean mass and strength, and increases fat mass. One small longitudinal study of transgender women runners found average race times slowed by 14.6% after about 31 months of therapy.

Is testosterone suppression enough to make competition fair?

The evidence is mixed. Some studies show key fitness measures converging with cisgender female ranges, while one review argues suppression produces only modest strength reductions over typical eligibility timeframes and may not remove all male-puberty advantages.

Why is the research on transgender athletes considered limited?

Most studies involve small numbers of participants, have limited longitudinal follow-up and use differing sports and testing methods. Data on elite athletes in specific sports remain especially scarce.

Related questions