Stronger evidence: ForVerdict
The evidence supporting the proposition that AI stocks face a crash due to circular deals is more comprehensive and empirically grounded. The 'for' side presents concrete market data showing CoreWeave's 52% decline coinciding with circular financing scrutiny, providing real-world validation of theoretical concerns. The Bank for International Settlements bulletin documenting $108B in hyperscaler debt with $1.5T projected, routed through off-balance-sheet vehicles, carries significant institutional weight and draws explicit parallels to pre-crisis financial patterns. Acemoglu's NBER analysis revealing a substantial gap between modest productivity projections (0.66% over a decade) and aggressive market assumptions provides rigorous academic backing for overvaluation concerns. The Greenwood et al. study establishing that rapid credit and asset price growth predicts 40% crisis probability within three years offers a robust empirical framework that the current AI capex cycle appears to fit. However, the 'against' evidence presents meaningful counterarguments. Nvidia's Q1 FY27 revenue of $81.6B with 85% year-over-year growth and diversified customer base suggests genuine underlying demand rather than mere accounting artifacts. The GitHub Copilot study demonstrating 55.8% productivity improvements provides concrete evidence of real-world AI value creation, distinguishing it from previous bubbles where underlying demand never materialized. Jensen Huang's public rebuttals, while not independent academic verification, directly address the circular deal critique with industry-specific context. Despite these valid counterpoints, the 'for' side's evidence is more systematic and draws from multiple authoritative sources including central banking analysis, peer-reviewed academic research, and actual market performance data. The combination of theoretical framework, institutional warnings, and emerging market corrections creates a more compelling case than the opposing evidence of continued revenue growth and productivity gains.
Ranked by citation count.
The debate
Andre: James, we're witnessing history repeat itself with AI circular deals creating a house of cards. CoreWeave's stock plummeted 52% the moment scrutiny hit their circular financing schemes. That's not coincidence, that's reality crashing into fantasy.
James: One company's troubles don't define an entire sector, Andre. Nvidia just posted $81.6 billion in Q1 revenue with 85% year-over-year growth across a diversified customer base. That's real money from real customers, not accounting tricks.
Andre: Real customers? The Bank for International Settlements documented $108 billion in hyperscaler debt, projected to hit $1.5 trillion, all flowing through off-balance-sheet vehicles. These aren't traditional customer relationships – they're elaborate financing loops designed to inflate demand artificially.
James: You're ignoring the productivity gains driving this growth. GitHub Copilot studies show 55.8% productivity improvements in real-world applications. When has any bubble actually delivered measurable value like that? The dot-com crash happened because there was no substance beneath the hype.
Andre: Productivity gains don't justify valuations when the financing structure is fundamentally unstable. Daron Acemoglu's NBER analysis reveals AI will likely boost productivity by just 0.66% over a decade, yet market assumptions price in revolutionary transformation. The math simply doesn't work.
James: Acemoglu's projections are conservative academic modeling, but Jensen Huang and industry leaders are seeing exponential adoption rates that academic models can't capture. The real-world deployment is outpacing theoretical frameworks.
Andre: Huang has every incentive to talk up his market. Meanwhile, Greenwood's empirical research shows that rapid credit and asset price growth – exactly what we're seeing in AI – predicts a 40% crisis probability within three years. The current AI capex cycle fits this pattern perfectly.
James: But that research applies to traditional bubbles without underlying technological breakthroughs. We're not dealing with empty speculation here – AI is transforming entire industries from healthcare to manufacturing. The infrastructure being built has genuine utility.
Andre: Infrastructure built on circular financing is a mirage. When companies use vendor financing to buy equipment, then claim those purchases as independent demand, you get artificial market signals. The BIS explicitly compared this to pre-crisis financial patterns we should recognize.
James: Even if some financing arrangements are questionable, the diversified revenue streams and measurable productivity gains suggest there's substantial real demand underneath. You can't fake 85% revenue growth across multiple customer segments indefinitely.
Andre: You absolutely can when those customer segments are interconnected through complex financing webs. CoreWeave's crash is the canary in the coal mine. When the circular deals unwind, the entire sector will face the same reckoning.
James: CoreWeave was always a smaller player with questionable practices. The major hyperscalers have transparent financials and genuine enterprise adoption driving growth.
Andre: The BIS data shows this extends far beyond CoreWeave. We're looking at systemic risk across the entire AI infrastructure ecosystem. When $1.5 trillion in projected debt meets Acemoglu's modest productivity reality, the crash won't discriminate between major and minor players.
Frequently asked questions
What are circular deals in the AI industry?
They are arrangements in which chipmakers and hyperscalers invest in AI labs that then buy products from those same suppliers. Critics argue this can recycle money through a closed loop and inflate apparent demand.
Is Nvidia's revenue growth real or just circular financing?
Nvidia reported Q1 FY27 revenue of $81.6 billion, up 85% year over year, from customers including Microsoft, Amazon, Google, Oracle, Meta and sovereign buyers. That breadth suggests real demand, though critics point to the debt financing behind much AI spending.
Has any AI stock already crashed?
CoreWeave, a central AI-infrastructure company, fell 52% from a $187 peak to about $90 during Q2 2026. The decline coincided with reporting on circular financing and concerns about AI capacity demand.
Does AI actually improve productivity enough to justify current valuations?
A randomized study found programmers using GitHub Copilot completed a coding task 55.8% faster. However, an NBER analysis projects AI will raise total factor productivity by no more than 0.66% over a decade, well below what markets appear to assume.