Stronger evidence: AgainstVerdict
While the evidence presents mixed findings on charter schools and vouchers, the research opposing these policies demonstrates stronger methodological rigor and broader consistency. The evidence against school choice programs is anchored by multiple high-quality randomized controlled trials - the gold standard for causal inference - showing negative or null effects. The Louisiana voucher study found students experienced significant achievement declines in both ELA and math, while the Indiana analysis revealed statistically significant drops in math performance. The national lottery-based charter school evaluation found no average achievement benefits, and the long-term NYC voucher follow-up showed no meaningful effects on college outcomes.
The evidence favoring school choice, while including some compelling findings like the Florida charter school study showing higher graduation rates and earnings, relies more heavily on observational data that may be subject to selection bias. Even the experimental evidence supporting vouchers, such as the DC study, shows mixed results with only modest graduation improvements but limited test score gains. The Milwaukee voucher study, though positive, is from 1998 and may not reflect current educational contexts.
Particularly concerning is the recent peer-reviewed analysis documenting how charter schools contribute to racial hypersegregation, highlighting significant equity concerns that proponents must address. This finding is especially troubling given that school choice programs are often promoted as benefiting disadvantaged students.
While some studies show benefits for specific populations or in particular contexts, the preponderance of rigorous experimental evidence suggests that charter schools and voucher programs generally fail to deliver promised academic improvements and may exacerbate educational inequities. The consistency of null or negative findings across multiple randomized evaluations in different states and contexts provides compelling evidence that these policies, as currently implemented, do not effectively improve educational outcomes for participating students.
Ranked by citation count.
Frequently asked questions
Do school vouchers improve test scores?
The evidence is mixed and leans negative. Randomized lottery evidence from Louisiana found declines in ELA and math, and Indiana voucher users saw significant math declines, while an older Milwaukee study found math gains and a DC evaluation found smaller or mixed test-score effects.
Do charter schools outperform traditional public schools?
Results vary. A national CREDO study found charter students gained an extra 16 days of learning in reading and 6 in math each year, with the largest gains for Black and Hispanic students, but a national lottery-based study of charter middle schools found no average achievement impact.
Do charter schools or vouchers help students get into college?
Findings differ by program. Florida and Los Angeles charter studies found higher college enrollment and persistence, while a long-term NYC voucher follow-up found no significant effects on college enrollment or degrees, and a California study found charter students overall attended college at lower rates.
Do charter schools increase school segregation?
A recent peer-reviewed study of two cities found that traditional charter schools contribute to the hypersegregation of nonwhite students. It also raised questions about segregation even when diversity-focused charter models are used.