ClearFactAll topics

Should drug possession be decriminalized?

Decriminalizing drugs · 7 peer-reviewed studies for, 3 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: For

Verdict

Decriminalizing drug possession has its strongest evidence on one clear mechanism: reducing criminal-legal harms (arrest, prosecution, incarceration) without reliably worsening key public-safety indicators in the short run. Empirical work in Oregon and Washington shows large drops in possession arrests and no detected rise in violent-crime arrests, and a major 1-year analysis found no association with fatal overdose. Internationally, Portugal’s long-running shift is frequently cited as consistent with stable overall use and improved health and justice outcomes. The main counterweight is that results depend heavily on implementation and context. A prominent synthetic-control study attributed a 2021 increase in unintentional overdose deaths in Oregon to decriminalization, while other analyses emphasize confounding from fentanyl market shifts and the lag between legal change and treatment-system expansion. Reviews also highlight that evidence on broader outcomes (including mental health) can be thin or mixed depending on the jurisdiction and the policy package. Bottom line: as a standalone legal change, decriminalization is likelier to improve justice outcomes than to produce immediate health gains; the case is strongest when paired with fast, well-funded treatment, harm reduction, and public-order interventions.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Impact evaluations of drug decriminalisation and legal regulation on drug use, health and social harms: a systematic review (BMJ Open, 2020)

Ayden I Scheim, Nazlee Maghsoudi et al. · 50 citations

Comprehensive systematic review of 114 peer-reviewed studies evaluating effects of drug decriminalization and legal regulation on drug use and health outcomes. Found that across all substance use metrics, legal reform was most often not associated with increases in use, supporting the safety of decriminalization policies.

Strongest study against

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (7)

Impact evaluations of drug decriminalisation and legal regulation on drug use, health and social harms: a systematic review (BMJ Open, 2020)

Ayden I Scheim, Nazlee Maghsoudi et al. · 50 citations

Comprehensive systematic review of 114 peer-reviewed studies evaluating effects of drug decriminalization and legal regulation on drug use and health outcomes. Found that across all substance use metrics, legal reform was most often not associated with increases in use, supporting the safety of decriminalization policies.

Racial Disparities in Drug Arrest Before and After De Facto Decriminalization in Baltimore (American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2023)

Saba Rouhani, Catherine Tomko et al.

Study analyzing police and court records from Baltimore's de facto decriminalization policy (April 2020-December 2021) found significant immediate decline in street and processed arrests for drug possession. The policy was associated with concentrated arrest reductions in the Black community (82% of total decline), suggesting decriminalization may effectively reduce carceral exposure and racial disparities in drug enforcement.

Against (3)

Frequently asked questions

Does decriminalizing drugs increase overdose deaths?

The evidence is mixed. A one-year analysis of Oregon and Washington found no association with fatal overdose rates, while another study estimated an increase in unintentional overdose deaths in Oregon in 2021. Other analyses point to fentanyl market shifts as a confounding factor.

Does drug decriminalization lead to more drug use?

A systematic review of 114 studies found that legal reform was most often not associated with increases in use. Analysis of Portugal also found no major increases in drug use after decriminalization.

Does decriminalizing drugs increase crime?

Studies in Oregon and Washington found large reductions in possession arrests without increases in violent-crime arrests relative to comparison states. A broader review found no evidence of increases in violent or property crime in most contexts.

How does drug decriminalization affect racial disparities in arrests?

In Baltimore, de facto decriminalization was followed by an immediate decline in drug possession arrests. Black residents accounted for 82% of that decline, which suggests the policy may reduce racial disparities in drug enforcement.

Related questions