Stronger evidence: ForVerdict
Based on the available evidence, the case for democratic backsliding in the United States is stronger than the opposition. Three substantial studies provide empirical support for ongoing democratic erosion, while only one study offers a counterargument that addresses resilience rather than disputing the existence of backsliding itself. Grumbach's comprehensive analysis in the American Political Science Review examined nearly two decades of state-level data (2000-2018), demonstrating measurable declines in democratic performance correlated with Republican control of state governments. This longitudinal approach provides robust quantitative evidence of institutional degradation at the subnational level. Druckman's framework analysis further strengthens this position by identifying specific psychological mechanisms through which democratic backsliding occurs, examining how elites, media, and citizens contribute to democratic erosion through documented biases and threat perceptions. The international perspective adds another dimension, with survey data from nearly 12,000 respondents across twelve democracies showing that global perceptions of American democracy have deteriorated due to concerns about democratic backsliding. This external validation suggests the phenomenon is observable beyond domestic partisan interpretations. The single study arguing against backsliding, while methodologically sound, focuses primarily on democratic resilience and recovery pathways rather than challenging the fundamental premise that backsliding has occurred. The research acknowledges that political agency can influence outcomes but does not dispute the empirical evidence of democratic decline presented by the other studies. The weight of evidence, both in quantity and scope, supports the conclusion that the United States is experiencing measurable democratic backsliding, though the resilience study appropriately notes that such trends are not necessarily irreversible.
Ranked by citation count.
The debate
Kevin: Ryan, we need to face the uncomfortable truth - American democracy is backsliding, and the data proves it. Grumbach's study in the American Political Science Review analyzed nearly two decades of state-level data from 2000 to 2018, showing measurable declines in democratic performance correlated with Republican control of state governments.
Ryan: Hold on, Kevin. One study doesn't prove a crisis. American democracy has weathered storms before - the Civil War, Watergate, the Great Depression. We've always bounced back stronger. Our institutions are more resilient than you're giving them credit for.
Kevin: But it's not just one study! Druckman's framework analysis identifies the specific psychological mechanisms driving this erosion - how elites, media, and citizens contribute to democratic decline through documented biases and threat perceptions. We're seeing the playbook of backsliding in real time.
Ryan: You're cherry-picking research that fits your narrative. Studies on democratic resilience show that political agency can influence outcomes and that temporary setbacks don't equal permanent decline. Democracy isn't as fragile as you think.
Kevin: Then explain this - survey data from nearly 12,000 respondents across twelve democracies shows that global perceptions of American democracy have deteriorated due to concerns about backsliding. When the entire democratic world is worried about us, that's not partisan fear-mongering, that's objective reality.
Ryan: International perceptions can be influenced by sensationalized media coverage. Just because other countries think we're struggling doesn't mean our democratic foundations are crumbling. We've had peaceful transfers of power, functioning courts, and active civil society.
Kevin: Peaceful transfers of power? Did you forget January 6th? That's exactly the kind of institutional stress that Grumbach's longitudinal data captures. We're seeing voter suppression, gerrymandering, and attacks on election integrity at the state level - measurable, documented erosion.
Ryan: January 6th was condemned across the political spectrum and the system held. The courts rejected election challenges, officials certified results, and democracy continued. That's resilience in action, not backsliding.
Kevin: But that's missing the forest for the trees. Even your resilience studies don't dispute that backsliding has occurred - they just argue it's potentially reversible. The fundamental premise that American democracy has declined is accepted even by researchers focused on recovery pathways.
Ryan: Temporary decline isn't permanent backsliding. Democracy is messy and cyclical. We're in a rough patch, sure, but calling it irreversible backsliding is premature and alarmist.
Kevin: Three substantial studies versus one that doesn't even deny the decline happened - just argues we might recover. The weight of evidence is overwhelming. Grumbach's quantitative data, Druckman's psychological mechanisms, and international validation all point to the same conclusion: American democracy is measurably weaker than it was twenty years ago.
Ryan: Correlation isn't causation, and temporary weakness isn't permanent failure. American democracy has survived worse.
Kevin: The question isn't whether we'll survive - it's whether we'll acknowledge what's happening before it's too late to reverse course.
Frequently asked questions
What is democratic backsliding?
Democratic backsliding refers to the erosion of democracy. Research on the U.S. points to examples such as voting restrictions, limits on free speech, gerrymandering and attacks on judicial independence.
Is democratic backsliding happening at the state level in the U.S.?
Studies of U.S. states suggest it is. One analysis of 2000 to 2018 found state governments have been leaders in backsliding, and another links attacks on judicial independence to other declines in democratic performance.
Can democratic backsliding in the United States be reversed?
One study argues that regime outcomes are not predetermined and that political agency and institutional levers can support recovery. An experiment also found that most Americans were willing to remove backsliding incumbents at the ballot box.
How does U.S. democratic backsliding affect America's image abroad?
A study of 11,810 respondents across 12 democracies found that learning about U.S. democratic backsliding reduced favorable views of the United States.