ClearFactAll topics

Is Peggy Flanagan more likely to win the Minnesota Senate than Michele Tafoya?

Result

✅ Flanagan won · Flanagan 54.6%, Tafoya 42.8%

Vote shares as of about 73% counted.

Source · unofficial results

Stronger evidence: Flanagan

Verdict

Minnesota's open Senate seat pits Democratic Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan against Republican Michele Tafoya, a former sports broadcaster running her first campaign. Flanagan is a two-term statewide official with an existing organization, and Minnesota has not elected a Republican U.S. senator in decades, giving the Democratic nominee a clear structural advantage. Tafoya brings name recognition and the ability to draw media attention, but faces both a blue-leaning map and an experience gap. The verdict favors Flanagan, subject to re-derivation once polling lands.

Open the interactive page →

Matchup data

Flanagan (15)

Tafoya (16)

The debate

Lisa: Flanagan has been Lieutenant Governor since 2019 and just won a real primary. Minnesota hasn't sent a Republican to the Senate in a generation. That's a lean-Democratic seat.

James: Tafoya has statewide name recognition from sportscasting and can command attention and self-fund. Don't underestimate a celebrity outsider in an angry cycle.

Lisa: Name recognition isn't the same as a record. Flanagan can run on governing experience; Tafoya has never held office.

James: Outsider status is a feature to a lot of voters right now. But I agree the map is the bigger fact here.

Lisa: Right — blue-leaning state, experienced nominee. Flanagan favored, re-check with polling.

Related questions