Defensive Gun Uses: New Evidence from a National Survey (Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 1998)
Reports defensive gun use exists at nontrivial levels in a national survey and discusses measurement uncertainty around prevalence.
All topicsGun Ownership · 3 peer-reviewed studies for, 5 against
Evidence for gun ownership benefits is strongest on the claim that defensive gun use occurs, and data sources like the NCVS can bound its frequency. However, those studies largely establish incidence, not net benefit: they do not show that widespread ownership reduces overall victimization or fatalities, and measurement is sensitive to definitions and reporting biases. In contrast, the evidence linking household firearm access to lethal harm is more consistent and directly tied to outcomes that are hard to misclassify (death). A classic case-control study finds higher homicide risk in homes with guns, and a major systematic review/meta-analysis concludes firearm accessibility is associated with increased risk of suicide and homicide victimization among household members. Taken together, defensive uses exist but appear relatively infrequent compared with the magnitude of documented risks in the home, especially for suicide. On balance, the evidence-weighted position is against the claim that broad household gun ownership is net-protective for public health; policies emphasizing reduced access for high-risk situations and safer storage are better supported than expanding ownership as a general safety strategy.
Ranked by citation count.
Reports defensive gun use exists at nontrivial levels in a national survey and discusses measurement uncertainty around prevalence.
This peer-reviewed epidemiological study conducted a negative binomial regression analysis of CDC data across all 50 US states from 1981-2010. The study found that gun ownership was a significant predictor of firearm homicide rates, with each percentage point increase in gun ownership associated with a 0.9% increase in firearm homicide rates, controlling for state-level confounders.
Reports defensive gun use exists at nontrivial levels in a national survey and discusses measurement uncertainty around prevalence.
Using NCVS data, estimates defensive firearm use occurs at relatively low but persistent levels over decades, providing an empirical baseline for defensive-use claims.
Study of Pennsylvania gun owners found most have received safety training and take appropriate precautions. Significantly, 1 in 4 gun owners reported using firearms in self-defense at some point in their life, supporting the protective utility of civilian gun ownership for law-abiding citizens.
This peer-reviewed epidemiological study conducted a negative binomial regression analysis of CDC data across all 50 US states from 1981-2010. The study found that gun ownership was a significant predictor of firearm homicide rates, with each percentage point increase in gun ownership associated with a 0.9% increase in firearm homicide rates, controlling for state-level confounders.
Case-control analysis finds having a gun in the home is associated with higher risk of homicide in the home rather than protection.
Systematic review and meta-analysis finds firearm access is associated with increased risk of completed suicide and homicide victimization among household members.
Cohort study examining temporal sequencing of firearm ownership and mortality from 1990-2018. Found higher household firearm ownership rates preceded increases in firearm suicide rates, establishing temporal causality linking gun ownership to increased suicide mortality.
This cross-sectional study of 1,100 urban youth found that youth with potential firearm access demonstrate significantly more violence risk and behavioral health issues than youth without access, and parental firearm ownership predicts youth firearm possession.
Research confirms defensive gun use happens, but estimates vary with how it is defined and reported. National crime victimization data suggest it occurs at relatively low but steady levels over time.
Yes, according to the available evidence. A systematic review and meta-analysis found firearm access is associated with increased risk of completed suicide among household members, and a cohort study found rises in household gun ownership preceded increases in firearm suicide rates.
The research reviewed does not show that it does. A case-control study found a gun in the home was associated with a higher risk of homicide in the home, not protection.
One study of all 50 states from 1981 to 2010 found gun ownership was a significant predictor of firearm homicide rates. Each percentage point increase in ownership was associated with a 0.9% increase in firearm homicide rates after controlling for state-level factors.