Several studies link higher H-1B admissions to more patenting and to productivity and wage gains for native workers, especially the college-educated.
Payroll data from large accounting firms found no evidence that H-1B hiring lowers wages for comparable U.S. citizen new hires.
Research using H-1B lotteries finds each extra visa may crowd out about 1.5 other workers at a firm, with little effect on innovation.
Other studies report lower STEM wages from immigration and estimate that H-1B workers earn 15-16% less than comparable native workers.
On balance, the evidence leans against broad limits and toward reforms such as wage- or skill-based selection and stricter enforcement.
Stronger evidence: Against
Verdict
The best-identified evidence does not support broad, across-the-board limits on H-1B visas as a welfare-improving policy. High-quality empirical work links higher H-1B admissions to increased innovation (patenting) and, in city-level analyses, to productivity gains and higher wages for natives—especially college-educated workers—suggesting meaningful complementarities in STEM-intensive labor markets. Recent payroll-based evidence also weakens a core popular rationale for limiting the program by finding no measurable wage depression for comparable U.S. citizen new hires in a setting often alleged to have underpayment. The strongest arguments for limiting are more targeted: lottery-based allocation can induce costly rent-seeking and search externalities, and firm-level lottery evidence finds that additional H-1Bs can crowd out other workers within the same firm and produce only modest innovation effects. Those results argue for reforming allocation (e.g., prioritization by wage/skill, stricter enforcement, and constraints on outsourcing-driven usage) rather than simply shrinking the program. Overall, the evidence-weighted position is against limiting H-1B visas in aggregate, and in favor of tighter targeting and anti-abuse design to preserve innovation benefits while reducing displacement and inefficiency.
Kirk Doran, Alexander Gelber et al. · 83 citations
Using H-1B lottery data matched to tax and patent data, this study finds that winning one additional H-1B visa crowds out approximately 1.5 other workers at the firm, with minimal effects on firm innovation. The findings support limiting H-1B expansion.
William R. Kerr and William F. Lincoln · 615 citations
Finds higher H-1B admissions increase immigrant STEM employment and patenting, with limited negative effects on native STEM employment or patenting in most specifications.
Kirk Doran, Alexander Gelber et al. · 83 citations
Using H-1B lottery data matched to tax and patent data, this study finds that winning one additional H-1B visa crowds out approximately 1.5 other workers at the firm, with minimal effects on firm innovation. The findings support limiting H-1B expansion.
Kirk Doran, Alexander Gelber et al. · 83 citations
Finds winning additional H-1B visas can crowd out other workers within the firm and yields at most modest innovation effects, supporting tighter limits or targeting.
Models and estimates efficiency losses from lottery-based allocation and search externalities, suggesting tighter constraints or stricter rules could reduce waste and abuse.
Study finds that a 10-percentage point increase in immigrant-native ratio in a skill group decreases relative wages by 1%, and estimates STEM wages fell 4-12% from immigration during 1990-2010, using H-1B visa cap changes as an instrument for identification.
Borjas analyzes I-129 petition data and American Community Survey data to find that H-1B workers earn 15-16% less than comparable native workers with same education, occupation, age, gender, and location. Firms save approximately $100,000 per H-1B hire over a six-year visa term due to the wage gap.
William R. Kerr and William F. Lincoln · 615 citations
Finds higher H-1B admissions increase immigrant STEM employment and patenting, with limited negative effects on native STEM employment or patenting in most specifications.
Uses variation tied to the H-1B program to identify STEM supply increases and finds higher productivity and wage gains for natives, especially college-educated workers.
Thomas Bourveau, Derrald Stice et al. · 1 citations
Using payroll data, finds no evidence H-1B hiring depresses peer U.S. citizen new-hire wages (and possibly small positive effects), weakening broad wage-suppression claims.
Study analyzing FY2024 H-1B visa applications found H-1B-sponsored physicians were nearly 2x more prevalent in rural counties and 4x more prevalent in high-poverty counties, demonstrating disproportionate reliance in vulnerable communities that would be hardest hit by visa restrictions.
This systematic review and meta-analysis examines the relationship between high-skilled immigration and innovation, with a focus on firm-level outcomes. The study identifies cultural diversity, demographic factors, and educational backgrounds as key drivers of innovation through patenting activity, providing comprehensive evidence that immigration positively impacts innovation metrics.
Frequently asked questions
Do H-1B visas lower wages for American workers?
The evidence is mixed. One study estimates STEM wages fell 4-12% from immigration during 1990-2010, and another finds H-1B workers earn 15-16% less than comparable natives. Payroll-based and city-level studies found no wage depression for comparable U.S. citizen new hires and found wage gains for natives.
Do H-1B workers take jobs from Americans?
A study of H-1B lottery winners found that each additional visa crowds out roughly 1.5 other workers within the same firm. Other research found limited negative effects on native STEM employment in most specifications.
Does the H-1B program increase innovation?
Research links higher H-1B admissions to more immigrant STEM employment and patenting, and a meta-analysis finds high-skilled immigration positively affects innovation measures. However, firm-level lottery evidence shows only minimal or modest innovation effects.
How would limiting H-1B visas affect health care?
An analysis of FY2024 applications found H-1B-sponsored physicians were nearly twice as prevalent in rural counties and four times as prevalent in high-poverty counties. Restrictions could therefore hit those communities hardest.