The Effect of Minimum Wages on Low-Wage Jobs (The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2019)
Finds that low-wage employment is largely unchanged after minimum-wage hikes, with job losses below the new minimum offset by gains at/just above it.
All topicsMinimum wage increases · 13 peer-reviewed studies for, 4 against
Minimum-wage increases reliably raise pay for affected workers; the real dispute is how much employment is reduced, for whom, and at what size of increase. High-profile U.S. evidence finds small or undetectable net job losses in many settings, including large panel analyses that show “missing” jobs below the new minimum often offset by gains just above it. Theory and review work also emphasizes channels that can dampen job loss—imperfect competition in low-wage labor markets, productivity adjustments, and partial pass-through to prices. But the literature is not unanimous: prominent critiques argue that some research designs understate disemployment by comparing inappropriate control areas or by smoothing away local shocks, and they find that negative effects for low-skill/teen workers remain plausible. The most defensible takeaway is conditional: modest, well-phased increases in normal times tend to deliver wage gains with limited aggregate employment effects, while very large or rapid hikes—especially in low-productivity regions or during downturns—carry higher risk of reduced hours, slower hiring, or sectoral job loss. Overall, the balance of evidence favors minimum-wage increases as a useful tool when calibrated to local conditions and paired with enforcement and evaluation.
Ranked by citation count.
Finds that low-wage employment is largely unchanged after minimum-wage hikes, with job losses below the new minimum offset by gains at/just above it.
Argues that methodological choices can mask employment losses and that the overall literature does not justify a blanket “no job loss” conclusion.
Finds that low-wage employment is largely unchanged after minimum-wage hikes, with job losses below the new minimum offset by gains at/just above it.
Epidemiological study analyzing 31 years of state minimum wage data (1980-2011) found that each dollar increase in minimum wage was associated with 1-2% decrease in low birth weight births and 4% decrease in postneonatal mortality. Results suggest that expanding minimum wages could prevent thousands of infant deaths annually.
Study finds that minimum wage increases substantially reduce dropout rates for low-socioeconomic status teens, potentially increasing their long-run productivity and labor market prospects despite potential short-term employment effects.
Defends and reinforces findings of little-to-no job loss from a prominent minimum-wage increase case study.
Study analyzing 138 state-level minimum wage increases from 1979-2016 found that the overall number of low-wage jobs remained essentially unchanged following increases, while wages increased and were amplified by modest wage spillovers. No evidence of disemployment at higher minimum wage levels.
Argues that negative employment effects of minimum-wage increases are hard to detect and may be attenuated by imperfect competition and pass-through channels.
Comprehensive meta-analysis of 88 minimum wage studies showing median own-wage elasticity of -0.13, indicating that only about 13% of potential earnings gains are offset by job losses, with post-2010 estimates trending closer to zero.
Global study of 87 countries using Gallup World Poll data (2009-2020) finds that minimum wage increases improve self-reported health and subjective well-being among low-skilled workers, with effects arising from both income and substitution channels.
Schemmel and Picot argue that minimum wages are justified on grounds of respect and recognition theory. They contend that minimum wages express respect for workers' contributions to society and are essential to economic citizenship, enabling workers to participate meaningfully in their social contexts.
Study finds that more highly concentrated labor markets experience more positive employment effects from minimum wage increases, with employment actually rising in the most concentrated markets. This demonstrates that minimum wages can have employment benefits under certain market conditions.
Study examining Germany's minimum wage found it raised wages without lowering employment and led to reallocation of low-wage workers to higher-paying establishments, suggesting minimum wage policies can improve worker outcomes with minimal negative employment effects.
Using 1979-2019 CPS data, analyzes effects of state and federal minimum wages on gender, race, and ethnic wage inequality. Finds minimum wages substantially reduce between-group wage inequality at lower wage percentiles, with no adverse employment effects and counterfactual evidence that minimum wage declines in the 1980s slowed progress on inequality.
California's April 2024 policy raising the minimum wage to $20 for fast food workers increased average weekly wages by 11% with no employment reduction. The study uses granular payroll and mobility data to show employers passed about 50% of higher wage costs to consumers as a 1.5% price increase.
Argues that methodological choices can mask employment losses and that the overall literature does not justify a blanket “no job loss” conclusion.
Reassesses recent minimum-wage designs and concludes that disemployment effects for low-skill workers remain plausible and supported in parts of the evidence.
Challenges the original case-study conclusions using alternative data and argues for negative employment effects in that setting.
Using longitudinal administrative employment data from Washington State across 2013-2016, the study found that Seattle's minimum wage increases to $13 reduced hours of work significantly for low-wage workers, particularly the less experienced. While hourly wages increased, the hours reductions resulted in modest weekly earnings gains of $8-$12, with some workers experiencing negative overall earnings effects.
Ryan: Let's start with what's not in dispute. Raising the minimum wage raises pay for the workers it covers. That's the whole point, and it works.
Daniel: But at what cost? Economics 101 says if you make labor more expensive, businesses buy less of it. Higher wages mean fewer jobs.
Ryan: That's the textbook model, but low-wage labor markets aren't textbook markets. Employers often have real power over wages because workers have limited options nearby. In that setting, a higher floor can raise pay without killing jobs.
Daniel: That's a convenient theory. Where's the evidence?
Ryan: Large U.S. panel studies. Researchers tracked jobs below and above the new minimum. Yes, jobs paying below the new floor disappear, but there's a matching increase in jobs just above it. The "missing" jobs aren't missing. They moved up.
Daniel: Or the researchers picked the wrong comparison areas. Critics argue that some studies compare states that aren't truly similar, so they smooth away local shocks and hide real job losses.
Ryan: Fair, and that criticism deserves attention. But even the critics mostly find effects concentrated among teens and the least skilled, not a collapse in employment. That's a debate about size and targeting, not about whether the policy works.
Daniel: Targeting matters. If the teenager or the low-skill worker loses hours or never gets hired, the average wage gain doesn't help them.
Ryan: Agreed, which is why design matters. Businesses also adapt in ways the simple model ignores. Turnover falls, productivity rises, and some costs get passed to customers in small price increases. Spread across millions of purchases, that's a modest cost.
Daniel: Small in a booming city, maybe. What about a low-productivity rural region? Or a recession? A big, fast hike there could mean cut hours, slower hiring, or closed shops.
Ryan: You're right, and I'll concede it. A very large or rapid increase in a weak local economy carries real risk. But that's an argument for calibrating, not abandoning. Phase increases in gradually, tie them to local conditions, and evaluate the results.
Daniel: Evaluate? Governments are terrible at admitting a policy failed.
Ryan: Then build it in. Pair increases with enforcement so employers can't dodge them, and set review points. Plenty of policy works that way.
Daniel: So your position is basically "it depends."
Ryan: My position is that in normal times, modest, well-phased increases deliver real wage gains with limited effects on overall employment. That's what most of the evidence shows. You're defending the risk at the extremes, and I've already granted that risk.
Daniel: The uncertainty still bothers me. Economists don't agree, and workers on the margin bear the downside.
Ryan: Uncertainty cuts both ways. We know the pay raise is certain. The job losses are uncertain, small where found, and manageable with smart design. When one side of the ledger is solid and the other is speculative, you take the solid gain and watch the risk.
Daniel: I'll give you this. The strongest version of your argument isn't "raise it as high as possible." It's "raise it carefully."
Ryan: Exactly. A calibrated minimum wage is a useful tool, and the evidence supports using it.
Daniel: Then my warning is simple: calibrate honestly, and don't ignore the people who get left behind.
Ryan: Deal. Build that into the policy, and we both get what we want.
Many studies find small or undetectable net job losses, especially for modest increases in normal economic times. Critics argue some research methods understate job losses, and effects may be larger for low-skill and teen workers.
Some of the cost is often passed on to consumers. A study of California's $20 fast food minimum wage found employers passed about half of higher wage costs to customers through a 1.5% price increase.
Yes, in some settings. A study of Seattle's increases to $13 found reduced hours for low-wage workers, particularly less experienced ones, leaving modest weekly earnings gains and losses for some workers.
The evidence suggests it does. Modest, well-phased increases tend to raise wages with limited employment effects, while very large or rapid hikes, especially in low-productivity regions or downturns, carry higher risk of reduced hours, slower hiring or job loss.