Should states allow no-excuse absentee and vote-by-mail voting?
No-excuse absentee / vote-by-mail · 6 peer-reviewed studies for, 7 against
Key takeaways
Studies of all-mail rollouts in Washington and Colorado found turnout gains, with larger effects among lower-propensity voters.
Multiple large administrative studies found universal or mandatory vote-by-mail did not systematically advantage either party.
No-excuse mail ballots improved voting access and turnout for people with disabilities, who face obstacles at polling places.
Natural experiments in Texas, Indiana and California found little or no turnout gain, and in one case possibly lower turnout than polling-place voting.
Signature checks and procedural errors can reject valid ballots, falling hardest on inexperienced voters and voters with Hispanic surnames.
Stronger evidence: For
Verdict
No-excuse absentee and broader vote-by-mail (VBM) reforms generally improve access and tend to increase participation modestly in many real-world rollouts, while evidence from multiple large administrative studies indicates these policies do not systematically advantage one party. That makes the core pro-policy case strong: convenience voting can reduce friction for workers, caregivers, students, and people with mobility or transportation constraints, and the best causal designs often find small turnout gains (or at least no harm) at scale. However, benefits are not automatic. Some contexts show little or even negative turnout effects versus polling-place voting, and administrative “failure points” matter: signature verification, late arrivals, and paperwork errors can reject ballots, disproportionately harming less-experienced voters unless notice-and-cure and tracking systems are robust. The practical verdict is therefore conditional but favorable: adopt no-excuse absentee/VBM with strong implementation guardrails—clear instructions, prepaid postage or drop boxes, ballot tracking, standardized verification, and generous cure windows. With those in place, the access and participation benefits are more likely to dominate the rejection and administrative-risk downsides.
Alan S. Gerber, Gregory A. Huber et al. · 108 citations
Finds Washington’s staggered adoption of all-mail elections increased turnout by roughly 2–4 percentage points and reduced turnout gaps between low- and high-propensity voters.
Applies Bayesian analysis to mail ballot signature verification, finding that election workers are statistically more likely to wrongly reject valid ballots for signature mismatch than to correctly reject invalid returns, highlighting systemic errors in signature-matching processes used to reject mail ballots.
Alan S. Gerber, Gregory A. Huber et al. · 108 citations
Finds Washington’s staggered adoption of all-mail elections increased turnout by roughly 2–4 percentage points and reduced turnout gaps between low- and high-propensity voters.
Daniel M. Thompson, Jennifer A. Wu et al. · 82 citations
Design-based analyses find universal vote-by-mail does not systematically advantage either party in turnout or vote share, weakening claims that expanded mail voting is partisan manipulation.
Adam Bonica, Jacob M. Grumbach et al. · 23 citations
Study exploiting Colorado's 2014 all-mail voting implementation found a positive turnout effect of approximately 8 percentage points, with significantly larger effects among lower-propensity voting groups including young people, blue-collar workers, and voters of color.
Jonathan Auerbach and Steve Pierson · 20 citations
Auerbach and Pierson (2021) analyze reported voter fraud cases using Heritage Foundation and News21 databases to compare fraud rates between vote-by-mail and non-VBM states from 2000-2019. They find no evidence that voting by mail increases voter fraud risk overall, with RBM and VBM states showing similar fraud rates to comparable non-VBM states using synthetic control methods.
Shows mandatory vote-by-mail modestly increases turnout while not changing partisan outcomes, based on large-scale administrative data and staggered rollouts.
Research by Schur, Adya, and Ameri demonstrates that no-excuse mail ballot availability significantly improves voting accessibility and turnout among people with disabilities, who face substantial obstacles at polling places. The study recommends expanding no-excuse mail ballot availability as a best practice for reducing voting obstacles.
Applies Bayesian analysis to mail ballot signature verification, finding that election workers are statistically more likely to wrongly reject valid ballots for signature mismatch than to correctly reject invalid returns, highlighting systemic errors in signature-matching processes used to reject mail ballots.
Study finds inexperienced mail voters are up to three times more likely to have ballots rejected compared to experienced voters, with rejection disparities varying by party, race/ethnicity, and age, risking exacerbation of existing inequities in political representation.
Provides first causal evidence that no-excuse absentee voting policies did not meaningfully increase turnout in 2020 using natural experiments in Texas and Indiana with millions of voters, finding 65-year-olds voted at nearly same rates as 64-year-olds despite differential access to no-excuse absentee voting.
Using a natural experiment in California, finds vote-by-mail assignment did not increase turnout in general elections and may reduce participation relative to polling-place voting in that context.
Analyzes signature-verification processes and highlights how calibration and error tradeoffs can lead to nontrivial rejection rates, implying access gains may be offset by “lost votes” without strong cure processes.
Study finds that vote-by-mail ballots with Hispanic surnames are substantially more likely to be rejected for signature mismatch than those with non-Hispanic White surnames, with an experimental audit showing evaluator bias rather than voter-side factors drives racial disparities in ballot acceptance.
Procedural requirements for mail balloting create significant "lost votes" beyond rejected ballots. Pennsylvania's 2022 election showed at least 47% more lost votes than rejected mail ballots, with deterrence effects preventing some voters from returning ballots they expect to be rejected.
Frequently asked questions
Does vote-by-mail increase voter turnout?
Often, but modestly and not everywhere. Studies of all-mail elections in Washington and Colorado found turnout gains, while natural experiments in Texas, Indiana and California found little or no effect.
Does voting by mail favor Democrats or Republicans?
Large administrative studies found universal and mandatory vote-by-mail did not systematically change partisan turnout or vote share.
Does voting by mail increase voter fraud?
One study comparing reported fraud cases from 2000 to 2019 found no evidence that switching to mail elections increased fraud rates relative to comparable states.
Why do mail ballots get rejected?
Ballots can be rejected for signature mismatches, late arrival or paperwork errors. Research shows signature verification can wrongly reject valid ballots, and first-time mail voters are up to three times more likely to have ballots rejected, so tracking and cure processes matter.