Do private prisons increase recidivism rates compared to publicly operated facilities?
3 peer-reviewed studies for, 5 against
Key takeaways
Studies in Oklahoma and Minnesota found private prison inmates had higher recidivism, with estimates of about 16.7% and 22% higher rates.
A large Florida study found no significant recidivism difference between private and public prison inmates in 35 of 36 comparisons.
A meta-analysis of 12 studies found no clear benefit or detriment from private prisons, though public prisons offered slightly better skills training.
When higher recidivism is included in cost models, short-term savings from private prisons may be erased by long-term re-incarceration costs.
Reviewers caution that high-quality studies are scarce, so the evidence only modestly supports higher recidivism in private prisons.
Stronger evidence: For
Verdict
The weight of evidence modestly supports the conclusion that private prisons increase recidivism rates compared to publicly operated facilities, though the effect is not overwhelming and study quality varies. On the "for" side, the two strongest studies — Duwe and Clark (Criminal Justice Policy Review, 2013) and Spivak and Sharp (Crime & Delinquency, 2008) — both used rigorous methodology and found consistent results: private prison inmates showed higher recidivism in every model tested. Duwe and Clark found a roughly 22% higher recidivism rate in Minnesota using propensity score matching, attributing the difference to fewer visitation opportunities and reduced rehabilitative programming. Spivak and Sharp found a 16.7% greater recidivism rate in Oklahoma across eight survival analysis models. Mamun et al. (Applied Economics, 2020) added an important economic dimension, demonstrating that when higher recidivism rates are incorporated into cost models, the short-term savings of private prisons are erased by long-term costs of re-incarceration. On the "against" side, the largest study — Bales et al. (Criminology & Public Policy, 2005) — found no significant differences in Florida across 36 comparisons, though Florida's regulatory environment may not be representative. Lundahl et al.'s meta-analysis (Research on Social Work Practice, 2009) of 12 studies concluded private prisons provide no clear benefit or detriment, with similar quality of confinement but slightly worse skills training. Gaes (Criminology & Public Policy, 2019) cautioned that the overall research base lacks high-quality studies, limiting strong conclusions. The mechanism behind higher recidivism in private prisons is plausible: the profit motive incentivizes cost-cutting in areas like staffing, programming, and rehabilitation — exactly the investments that reduce reoffending. While the meta-analytic evidence suggests the gap may be small on average, the most methodologically rigorous individual studies consistently find private prisons performing worse on recidivism, tilting the evidence toward the "for" side.
Andrew L. Spivak and Susan F. Sharp · 77 citations
Analyzing a large cohort of Oklahoma adult male offenders released between 1997-2001 using multivariate survival analysis, private prison inmates had a greater hazard of recidivism in all eight models tested, six of which were statistically significant, with an estimated 16.7% greater recidivism rate.
Comprehensive literature review concluding that on average, costs and quality of privatized facilities appear to be about the same as publicly operated prisons. Cautioned that the lack of high-quality studies limits strong inference in either direction, and that lower costs in states with privatization may reflect strong cost controls rather than privatization itself.
Andrew L. Spivak and Susan F. Sharp · 77 citations
Analyzing a large cohort of Oklahoma adult male offenders released between 1997-2001 using multivariate survival analysis, private prison inmates had a greater hazard of recidivism in all eight models tested, six of which were statistically significant, with an estimated 16.7% greater recidivism rate.
Using propensity score matching on 3,532 offenders released between 2007-2009 in Minnesota, offenders incarcerated in private prisons had a greater hazard of recidivism in all 20 Cox regression models tested, with a roughly 22% higher recidivism rate attributed to fewer visitation opportunities and reduced rehabilitative programming.
Modeled long-term dynamic tradeoffs and found that while private prisons may offer short-term cost savings, when higher recidivism rates are factored in, public prisons are less costly in the long term. The estimated short-term cost efficiency of private prisons is not worth the long-term consequences of increased recidivism.
Comprehensive literature review concluding that on average, costs and quality of privatized facilities appear to be about the same as publicly operated prisons. Cautioned that the lack of high-quality studies limits strong inference in either direction, and that lower costs in states with privatization may reflect strong cost controls rather than privatization itself.
Meta-analysis of 12 head-to-head comparison studies found that privately managed prisons provide no clear benefit or detriment compared to public facilities. Cost savings from privatization are not guaranteed and appear minimal. Quality of confinement is similar, though public prisons delivered slightly better skills training and had fewer inmate grievances.
This large-scale study examined Florida prison inmates released between 1995-2001 using multivariate survival analysis and found no significant differences in recidivism rates between private and public prison inmates for adult males, adult females, or youthful male offenders. Only 1 of 36 comparisons showed a significant finding.
Study comparing experiences in private vs public prisons found males in private prisons perceived inadequate staffing and had less contact with people outside prison, factors associated with higher recidivism.
Mukherjee's peer-reviewed study examines private prison contracting in Mississippi and finds that private prison inmates serve 90 additional days (4.8% longer sentences) due to increased conduct violations, yet this extended time does not reduce recidivism, suggesting private prisons do not improve public safety outcomes despite longer incarceration.
The debate
Lisa: The two most rigorous studies on this question both point in the same direction. Duwe and Clark used propensity score matching in Minnesota and found a 22% higher recidivism rate for private prison inmates across all 20 models they tested. Spivak and Sharp found a 16.7% higher rate in Oklahoma using survival analysis. These aren't cherry-picked results — the effect was consistent across every specification.
James: But the largest study on the topic — Bales et al. in Florida — found no significant difference in 35 out of 36 comparisons. That's a massive dataset covering six years of releases. And Lundahl's meta-analysis of 12 studies concluded there's no clear benefit or detriment either way. The evidence is far from one-sided.
Lisa: Florida is one state with its own regulatory context. Minnesota and Oklahoma used more recent data and more rigorous matching methods. And even Lundahl's meta-analysis acknowledged that public prisons delivered better skills training and had fewer inmate grievances. Those are exactly the kinds of programming differences that drive recidivism outcomes.
James: Gaes reviewed the entire literature in 2019 and concluded that costs and quality are about the same on average. He also cautioned that the research base has serious quality limitations. We're making strong claims on a pretty thin evidence base.
Lisa: The mechanism is what makes the recidivism findings credible. Private prisons have a structural profit incentive to cut costs, and they do — in staffing ratios, rehabilitation programs, and mental health services. Duwe and Clark specifically identified fewer visitation opportunities and reduced programming as the pathway to higher recidivism. That's not a coincidence; it's the business model.
James: You could also argue that private operators have an incentive to innovate and find efficiencies that bloated public bureaucracies don't. Some private facilities have introduced evidence-based programs precisely because they compete for contracts based on outcomes. The profit motive can cut both ways.
Lisa: In theory, yes. In practice, Mamun et al. showed that when you factor recidivism into the cost equation, private prisons are actually more expensive in the long run. The short-term savings disappear because you're paying to re-incarcerate people who might not have reoffended under better conditions. The system is penny-wise and pound-foolish.
James: I'll concede the long-term cost argument is compelling. But I maintain that the recidivism evidence is mixed, not decisive. The difference between states suggests that regulation and contract design matter more than public versus private ownership. A well-regulated private prison can match public outcomes.
Lisa: Which raises the question: if you need heavy regulation to make private prisons perform as well as public ones, what exactly is the point of privatizing?
Frequently asked questions
Are private prisons cheaper than public prisons?
Reviews and a meta-analysis found costs roughly similar, with savings from privatization not guaranteed and appearing minimal. One economic model found that once higher recidivism is factored in, public prisons are less costly over the long term.
Why might private prisons lead to higher recidivism?
The Minnesota study linked higher recidivism to fewer visitation opportunities and reduced rehabilitative programming. A 2022 study found men in private prisons reported inadequate staffing and less contact with people outside prison, factors associated with reoffending.
Do inmates serve longer in private prisons?
A Mississippi study found private prison inmates served about 90 additional days, or 4.8% longer, due to more conduct violations. That extra time did not reduce recidivism.
Is the evidence on private prisons and recidivism conclusive?
No. The most rigorous individual studies point to higher recidivism in private prisons, but a large Florida study and a meta-analysis found little or no difference, and reviewers note a lack of high-quality research.