ClearFactAll topics

Do lower corporate tax rates meaningfully increase business investment?

4 peer-reviewed studies for, 3 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: For

Verdict

The evidence supports a real but heterogeneous relationship between corporate tax burdens and investment, with the strongest effects coming from changes to the tax rate on new capital (expensing, bonus depreciation, narrow effective-rate cuts) rather than from headline statutory-rate changes alone. On the "for" side, Djankov et al. (American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 2010) used a new cross-country dataset of effective corporate tax rates in 85 countries and found that a 10 percentage point higher effective rate is associated with a 2.2 percentage point lower aggregate investment-to-GDP ratio. Mertens and Ravn (American Economic Review, 2013) used a narrative-VAR identification of exogenous US tax changes and found that corporate rate cuts raise GDP and private investment in subsequent quarters. Ohrn (American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2018) exploited the Domestic Production Activities Deduction and estimated that a 1 percentage point reduction in the effective corporate rate raises firm investment by 4.7 percent of installed capital. Zwick and Mahon (American Economic Review, 2017), using IRS microdata on 120,000 firms, showed bonus depreciation raised eligible investment by 10-17 percent, with the largest responses among small and financially constrained firms — direct evidence that lowering the tax burden on new capital causes more capital formation. On the "against" side, Yagan (American Economic Review, 2015) found the 2003 US dividend tax cut had no detectable effect on corporate investment in a clean diff-in-diff between C- and S-corporations, with the windfall flowing to dividends instead. Auerbach (Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2018) argued the 2017 TCJA rate cut would likely produce smaller investment effects than its headline suggested, given simultaneous base changes and existing accelerated depreciation. Kawano and Slemrod (International Tax and Public Finance, 2016) showed statutory rate cuts in OECD data are systematically offset by base-broadening, so observed investment changes from headline rate cuts substantially overstate the pure rate effect. Taken together, the literature is most consistent with a "for" answer: corporate tax policy clearly affects investment, especially when it lowers the marginal tax on new capital, but pure statutory-rate cuts at the corporate level produce modest, sometimes undetectable, additional investment because the money flows to shareholders or is offset by base changes. The headline claim that lower corporate tax rates increase investment is supported, but with an important caveat that "rate" means effective rate on new capital, not the statutory rate that politicians usually focus on.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Tax Policy and Heterogeneous Investment Behavior (American Economic Review, 2017)

Eric Zwick and James Mahon · 484 citations

Using IRS tax-return microdata covering 120,000 firms, showed that bonus depreciation — a tax change that lowers the effective rate on new investment — raised eligible investment by 10.4 percent during 2001-2004 and 16.9 percent during 2008-2010. Effects were concentrated in small and financially constrained firms, demonstrating that targeted reductions in the corporate tax burden on new capital substantially increase real investment.

Strongest study against

Measuring the Effects of Corporate Tax Cuts (Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2018)

Alan J. Auerbach · 80 citations

Reviewed the economic theory and early empirical evidence on the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which cut the US statutory corporate rate from 35 to 21 percent. Concluded the eventual effects on investment were highly uncertain and likely much smaller than the headline rate change implied, because most assets already received accelerated depreciation, foreign earnings rules changed simultaneously, and corporate cash was already abundant. Warned that headline rate cuts often produce dividend and buyback responses more than capital formation.

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (4)

Tax Policy and Heterogeneous Investment Behavior (American Economic Review, 2017)

Eric Zwick and James Mahon · 484 citations

Using IRS tax-return microdata covering 120,000 firms, showed that bonus depreciation — a tax change that lowers the effective rate on new investment — raised eligible investment by 10.4 percent during 2001-2004 and 16.9 percent during 2008-2010. Effects were concentrated in small and financially constrained firms, demonstrating that targeted reductions in the corporate tax burden on new capital substantially increase real investment.

The Effect of Corporate Taxation on Investment and Financial Policy: Evidence from the DPAD (American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2018)

Eric Ohrn · 153 citations

Exploited variation in the US Domestic Production Activities Deduction, which lowered effective corporate tax rates for qualifying firms, and used Compustat data to show a 1 percentage point reduction in the effective corporate rate raised investment by 4.7 percent of installed capital. The estimated elasticity of investment with respect to the after-tax cost of capital was large and statistically significant.

The Effect of Corporate Taxes on Investment and Entrepreneurship (American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 2010)

Simeon Djankov, Tim Ganser et al.

Using a new cross-country dataset of effective corporate tax rates in 85 countries built from PricewaterhouseCoopers case studies, found that a 10 percentage point increase in the effective corporate tax rate is associated with a 2.2 percentage point reduction in the aggregate investment-to-GDP ratio. The relationship survived a wide range of controls and instrumental-variable robustness checks.

The Dynamic Effects of Personal and Corporate Income Tax Changes in the United States (American Economic Review, 2013)

Karel Mertens and Morten O Ravn

Using a narrative-VAR approach that isolates exogenous tax changes in US postwar data, found that a one percentage point cut in the average corporate income tax rate raises real GDP by about 0.4 percent within one quarter, with statistically significant increases in private investment in the quarters following the rate cut. The investment response was robust to alternative identification schemes.

Against (3)

Measuring the Effects of Corporate Tax Cuts (Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2018)

Alan J. Auerbach · 80 citations

Reviewed the economic theory and early empirical evidence on the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which cut the US statutory corporate rate from 35 to 21 percent. Concluded the eventual effects on investment were highly uncertain and likely much smaller than the headline rate change implied, because most assets already received accelerated depreciation, foreign earnings rules changed simultaneously, and corporate cash was already abundant. Warned that headline rate cuts often produce dividend and buyback responses more than capital formation.

How do corporate tax bases change when corporate tax rates change? With implications for the tax rate elasticity of corporate tax revenues (International Tax and Public Finance, 2016)

Laura Kawano and Joel Slemrod · 72 citations

Analysed OECD corporate tax data from 1980-2010 and found that statutory rate cuts are systematically accompanied by base-broadening reforms — eliminating credits, narrowing depreciation, restricting interest deductions — so the effective tax burden on investment changes much less than the headline rate. This pattern implies estimates that attribute investment responses to statutory-rate cuts alone substantially overstate the causal effect of "the corporate tax rate" on investment.

Capital Tax Reform and the Real Economy: The Effects of the 2003 Dividend Tax Cut (American Economic Review, 2015)

Danny Yagan

Used a difference-in-differences comparison of US C-corporations (affected by the 2003 dividend tax cut) and S-corporations (not affected), and found no detectable effect of the dividend tax cut on corporate investment or employee compensation. The reform did substantially raise dividend payouts, indicating the lower capital tax rate flowed to shareholders rather than into new real investment.

The debate

Lisa: There is genuinely strong evidence that corporate tax policy affects investment. Zwick and Mahon in the American Economic Review used IRS data on 120,000 firms and found bonus depreciation raised eligible investment by 10 to 17 percent, with the biggest effects in small, credit-constrained firms. Ohrn looked at the Domestic Production Activities Deduction and got a similar conclusion — a 1 percentage point cut in the effective corporate rate raised investment by 4.7 percent of installed capital.

James: Those papers are about expensing and base provisions, not about cutting the headline statutory rate. The cleanest test we have of a pure rate cut is Yagan's American Economic Review paper on the 2003 US dividend tax cut. Diff-in-diff comparing C-corps and S-corps. Zero effect on investment. The money went to dividends.

Lisa: Yagan is about dividend taxation, not the corporate rate itself, so it speaks to shareholder-side capital taxes. But on the corporate side, Mertens and Ravn ran a narrative-VAR on US postwar data and found corporate rate cuts do raise private investment within a few quarters. And Djankov and coauthors used effective rates across 85 countries and found a 10 point rate increase shaves 2.2 points off the investment-to-GDP ratio.

James: The Djankov cross-country result is fine but you have huge endogeneity issues — countries that cut rates also reform other policies. Kawano and Slemrod showed exactly that in OECD data: rate cuts come bundled with base broadening, so the effective burden barely moves and the rate-on-investment elasticity gets overstated.

Lisa: True. But that's an argument that the effective tax burden on new capital is what matters, not that taxes don't matter. When governments actually lower the marginal tax on new investment — through expensing, bonus depreciation, or DPAD — investment goes up. That's a consistent finding across very different data sets.

James: Auerbach made the same point in his JEP review of TCJA. He warned the 2017 rate cut would do less than the headline implied, because most assets already had accelerated depreciation and the cash was going to be returned to shareholders. That's basically what happened — buybacks surged, investment growth was modest.

Lisa: Modest, not zero. And the recent micro evidence on TCJA bonus depreciation extensions has shown real investment responses. The cleaner the variation in the marginal tax on new capital, the more clearly you see an effect.

James: Right. So the honest answer is: targeted incentives that lower the tax cost of buying new equipment clearly raise investment, but a generic statutory-rate cut at the corporate level produces a smaller, slower, and shareholder-heavy response.

Lisa: That's the synthesis. Lower corporate tax rates do increase investment, but the policy lever that moves the most capital per dollar of revenue lost is targeted expensing, not headline-rate cuts.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the statutory and effective corporate tax rate?

The statutory rate is the headline rate written in law, while the effective rate reflects what firms actually pay after deductions, credits and depreciation rules. The research reviewed finds investment responds most clearly to changes in the effective rate on new capital.

Does bonus depreciation increase business investment?

A study using IRS data on 120,000 firms found bonus depreciation raised eligible investment by 10.4 percent in 2001-2004 and 16.9 percent in 2008-2010. The largest responses came from small and financially constrained firms.

Did the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act boost investment?

A 2018 review concluded the investment effects of the law's cut from 35 to 21 percent were highly uncertain and likely smaller than the headline change implied. Reasons cited include existing accelerated depreciation, simultaneous changes to foreign earnings rules and already abundant corporate cash.

Where does the money from corporate tax cuts go if not into investment?

Some evidence suggests part of the benefit goes to shareholders through dividends and buybacks. A study of the 2003 US dividend tax cut found it raised dividend payouts substantially but had no detectable effect on investment or employee compensation.

Related questions