Stronger evidence: ForVerdict
The question is empirical: CAN large-scale rewilding of agricultural land effectively restore ecosystems and combat biodiversity loss? On the evidence, the answer is yes — with the caveats that the critics raise being important but not decisive. The 'for' case rests on convergent strands of evidence. Ripple and Beschta (Biological Conservation, 2012) documented the strongest single empirical case at Yellowstone: aspen browsing dropped from 100% to under 25% over 15 years after wolf reintroduction, with corresponding willow, aspen, and cottonwood recovery. More recent 20-year data shows a 1,500% increase in willow crown volume in northern Yellowstone — a trophic cascade strength exceeding 82% of those documented globally. Svenning et al. (PNAS, 2016) synthesize the broader scientific foundation, concluding that trophic rewilding via reintroductions and ecological replacements can re-establish self-regulating biodiverse ecosystems on simplified landscapes. Perino et al. (Science, 2019) sharpen this into an actionable framework — restore trophic complexity, disturbance, and dispersal — that explicitly applies to former agricultural land. Carver et al. (Conservation Biology, 2021) directly answer the critique that rewilding is conceptually unclear by deriving a unifying definition and 10 guiding principles from 59 experts. Real-world cases like the Knepp Estate in the UK (1,400 ha former arable and dairy farmland) document an 870% rise in dragonflies and damselflies, a 110% rise in butterfly species richness, recovery of nationally rare species like turtle doves, and a measured 16% increase in invertebrate species over a decade — exactly the agricultural-land restoration the question asks about. The 'against' case is real but narrower than it first appears. Nogués-Bravo et al. (Current Biology, 2016) raise legitimate concerns about definitional inconsistency and weak evidence for some top-down assumptions, but they argue for caution and rigor rather than that rewilding does not work. Hayward et al. (Biological Conservation, 2019) argue that rewilding is just restoration ecology rebranded — a critique about labels rather than effectiveness; even if it is correct, the substantive practices still produce restoration outcomes. Mech (Biological Conservation, 2012) shows that the Yellowstone trophic cascade has been overhyped in popular accounts and that confounders matter, but this refines rather than refutes the basic finding. Crucially, none of the 'against' papers presents evidence that large-scale rewilding has failed to restore ecosystems — they argue it is overstated, mislabeled, or oversold. The empirical record from Yellowstone, Knepp, and dozens of other documented sites shows that releasing pressure on agricultural land, reintroducing keystone species, and restoring natural processes does measurably increase biodiversity and ecosystem function. The verdict is 'for' — rewilding can effectively restore ecosystems and combat biodiversity loss when implemented with appropriate scale, monitoring, and intellectual humility about what it can and cannot do.
Ranked by citation count.
The debate
Lisa: The empirical record on this is unusually strong for a conservation question. Twenty years of data from Yellowstone — Ripple and Beschta in Biological Conservation 2012 — show that wolf reintroduction drove aspen browsing from 100% of measured leaders to under 25%, with cascading recovery of willow and cottonwood. More recent monitoring shows a 1,500% increase in riparian willow crown volume. That is not subtle. And Knepp Estate in England — 1,400 hectares of former arable and dairy land — documents an 870% rise in dragonflies, a 110% rise in butterfly species richness, and recovery of turtle doves that had declined 98% nationally. This is large-scale rewilding of agricultural land actually working.
James: I would push back on the Yellowstone story specifically. David Mech — arguably the world's leading wolf biologist — wrote in Biological Conservation in 2012 that the trophic-cascade claims have been overstated and that confounders like stream hydrology, climate, and external hunting pressure on elk muddy the causal story. The wolves matter, but the popular narrative has run far ahead of the evidence.
Lisa: Mech's critique is fair, and Ripple and Beschta themselves have refined their claims over time. But 'the cascade is more complex than first told' is not the same as 'rewilding does not work.' Subsequent meta-analyses still place the Yellowstone cascade in the top fifth of strengths globally. And the Knepp data does not depend on the Yellowstone story at all — it is a completely independent empirical case on former farmland.
James: Knepp is one private estate that became a media story. Nogués-Bravo, Simberloff, Rahbek, and Sanders in Current Biology 2016 — extremely heavyweight conservation biologists — wrote that rewilding has a definitional problem and that the assumed top-down control of ecosystems is empirically weaker than advocates claim. They explicitly called rewilding a 'Pandora's box.'
Lisa: Carver and colleagues directly answered that critique in Conservation Biology 2021 by surveying 59 rewilding experts and producing a unifying definition with 10 guiding principles. The definitional problem is a known issue that the field has worked on, not a fatal flaw. And Perino et al. in Science 2019 sharpened the operational framework — trophic complexity, disturbance, dispersal — into something testable and implementable on former agricultural land.
James: Hayward et al. in Biological Conservation 2019 made an important point you are skipping: every legitimate goal of rewilding already fits inside the well-established field of restoration ecology, which has decades of methodology and accountability. 'Rewilding' is largely restoration with better PR. If that is true, the question of whether rewilding 'works' is just the question of whether restoration works — which is much older and more nuanced than the rewilding hype implies.
Lisa: Even if Hayward is right that rewilding is a subset of restoration, the question is whether the PRACTICE works on agricultural land — the label is secondary. And rewilding does emphasize things conventional restoration often does not: large-scale process-based approaches, free-roaming herbivores, minimal management, predator reintroduction. Svenning et al. in PNAS 2016 synthesized the trophic-rewilding evidence and concluded the approach can restore self-regulating biodiverse ecosystems.
James: 'Can' is doing a lot of work in that sentence. Some sites succeed. Others — Oostvaardersplassen in the Netherlands is the famous example — produced animal welfare scandals and starvation events that derailed the whole project. Outcomes are highly site-specific and depend on management decisions that critics say rewilding underplays.
Lisa: Oostvaardersplassen is a real cautionary tale. But pointing to one failure does not erase Knepp's 870% rise in dragonflies, Yellowstone's aspen recovery, or the dozens of European trophic-rewilding sites with documented biodiversity gains. The question was 'can rewilding effectively restore ecosystems' — the answer is clearly yes, the qualifier is 'when implemented well.'
James: I would accept 'can, sometimes, with rigor and good monitoring.' I would not accept the stronger claim that large-scale rewilding is a reliable solution to the biodiversity crisis on a planetary scale. The evidence supports modest and conditional optimism, not the breathless framing it often gets.
Lisa: That is the realistic version of yes. And it is the answer to the question.
Frequently asked questions
What is rewilding?
Rewilding is an approach to restoration that aims to rebuild self-sustaining ecosystems by restoring natural processes. One framework focuses on three of them: species interactions across the food web, natural disturbance, and dispersal. A 2021 study drew on 59 experts to set out a unifying definition and 10 guiding principles.
Does rewilding farmland reduce food production?
One study suggests that setting aside at least 20% of agricultural land for rewilding, alongside wildlife-friendly practices on the remaining farmland, could reverse biodiversity declines while maintaining food production. A 15-year agriwilding system in Belgium restored butterfly and moth diversity while keeping its capacity to produce food.
Did wolves really restore Yellowstone's ecosystem?
Research documented reduced browsing and recovery of aspen, willow and cottonwood after wolves were reintroduced in 1995–96. Wolf biologist L. David Mech argues the popular account is exaggerated, because hydrology, climate and elk numbers also influenced vegetation recovery.
What are the main criticisms of rewilding?
Critics point to competing definitions and weak evidence for some core assumptions. They also warn of unintended effects, such as impacts from invasive species. Some argue rewilding is simply restoration ecology under a new name. These critiques question how the approach is described and promoted rather than presenting evidence that rewilding has failed to restore ecosystems.