ClearFactAll topics

Should governments prioritize funding for small modular reactors over conventional large-scale nuclear plants?

4 peer-reviewed studies for, 8 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: Against

Verdict

SMRs have a plausible economic story—factory fabrication, standardization, shorter schedules, and portfolio-style risk reduction—supported by reviews and expert elicitations, and by niche analyses where coal-site reuse and policy incentives make multi-unit SMR programs look competitive. But the core economic uncertainty is still unresolved: SMRs generally face diseconomies of scale and require high-volume, repeat builds to realize “economy of multiples,” which is exactly what has not yet been proven in commercial practice. Systematic reviews emphasize that SMR cost and financing estimates vary widely and depend on assumptions about serial production, regulatory streamlining, and supply-chain maturity. Bottom-up techno-economic work likewise shows outcomes are highly sensitive to FOAK penalties and deployment conditions rather than an inherent SMR advantage. Meanwhile, historical evidence on large reactors indicates that when countries develop strong delivery capability and repeat standardized builds, costs can be contained—suggesting that execution and learning-by-doing matter more than simply choosing smaller units. Net: governments should fund SMR R&D and first-of-a-kind demonstrations, but not prioritize SMRs over large-scale plants as the main bet; the evidence favors a diversified approach with strict performance milestones before scaling SMR subsidies.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Strongest study against

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (4)

Against (8)

Challenges of small modular reactors: A comprehensive exploration of economic and waste uncertainties associated with U.S. small modular reactor designs (Progress in Nuclear Energy, 2025)

Philseo Kim and Allison Macfarlane

A comprehensive analysis of U.S. SMR designs showing considerable uncertainty in LCOE estimations, with SMRs having significantly more economic and waste management challenges than large reactors. The study examines capital costs, fuel cycle costs, operating expenses, and waste production across multiple SMR types.

Frequently asked questions

Are small modular reactors cheaper than large nuclear plants?

Not on current evidence. Several studies find SMRs have higher costs per kW because they lose economies of scale, and one modeled analysis found smaller reactors failed to reach cost parity with larger ones even with learning-by-doing.

What is the "economy of multiples" argument for SMRs?

It is the idea that building many identical small reactors in factories, with standardized designs and learning between builds, could offset the cost advantages of building one large reactor. Reviews note this depends on high-volume, repeat builds that have not yet been demonstrated in commercial practice.

Can SMRs be built faster than large reactors?

Expert assessments and model-based analyses suggest SMRs may achieve shorter construction times under serial production and factory fabrication. These projections rely on assumptions about supply-chain maturity and regulatory streamlining that remain uncertain.

Should governments invest in SMRs at all?

The weight of evidence supports funding SMR research and first-of-a-kind demonstrations rather than making SMRs the main bet over large plants. A diversified approach with clear performance milestones before scaling SMR subsidies is favored.

Related questions