Against (8)
Anthony Asuega, Braden J. Limb et al.
Bottom-up costing across SMR designs finds costs remain highly sensitive to FOAK effects and deployment assumptions, and does not show clear inherent cost superiority versus a conventional large reactor baseline.
B. Mignacca and G. Locatelli
Systematic review highlights large uncertainty in SMR cost estimates and financing, emphasizing that commercialization depends on successful standardization, volume, and de-risking that is not yet demonstrated.
Jessica R. Lovering, Arthur Yip et al.
Reactor-level historical data show wide cost variation driven by country experience, supply chains, and delivery capability, implying cost competitiveness is more about execution and learning than reactor size alone.
Nick Van Hee, Herbert Peremans et al.
Systematic literature review finding that SMR capital costs per kW are 41% higher than large reactors, with average levelized cost of electricity of 85 €/MWh, and concluding that high capital costs, uncertainty, and low EU carbon prices limit SMR deployment economics.
Björn Steigerwald, Jens Weibezahn et al.
Monte Carlo analysis of 15 SMR projects found that none are able to compete economically with existing renewable technologies, even accounting for variability and system integration costs. All light water reactor SMRs exhibited significantly higher levelized costs than alternatives.
Philseo Kim and Allison Macfarlane
A comprehensive analysis of U.S. SMR designs showing considerable uncertainty in LCOE estimations, with SMRs having significantly more economic and waste management challenges than large reactors. The study examines capital costs, fuel cycle costs, operating expenses, and waste production across multiple SMR types.
Gustavo Alonso
Analyzes SMR economic competitiveness in net zero policies. Finds SMRs have higher cost per kW than large reactors due to loss of economies of scale. Concludes that SMR designs backed by national governments have higher success opportunities, but economic competitiveness remains challenging compared to large reactors.
Longitudinal risk analysis modeling cost and schedule uncertainties based on historical nuclear project data. Finds that economy of scale cost advantages typically outweigh increased risk for larger reactors, with cumulative deployments of smaller reactors failing to achieve cost parity with larger reactors when considering learning-by-doing effects.