McLaughlin and Associates (Completed September 17, 2026) - Oct 2026
Manny Rutinel polling: 46%
All topics✅ Rutinel won · Rutinel 55.4%, Evans 40.7%
Source · unofficial results
Colorado's 8th District is the state's only genuine toss-up, and it now features Democrat Manny Rutinel against first-term Republican incumbent Gabe Evans. Rutinel — a state legislator and former Earthjustice attorney placed on the DCCC's Red to Blue list — starts with national resources in a district Evans carried by under a point in 2024. In a D-leaning state in a midterm favoring the party out of the White House, the structural edge is narrow but points to the Democrat; incumbency and Evans' proven ability to win the seat keep it a coin flip. Re-derive once district polling is available.
Manny Rutinel polling: 46%
Manny Rutinel polling: 46%
Manny Rutinel polling: 46%
Manny Rutinel polling: 46%
3-month average US search interest for Manny Rutinel: 18/100
3-month average US search interest for Manny Rutinel: 5/100
3-month average US search interest for Manny Rutinel: 4/100
30-day page views for Manny Rutinel: 38,481
30-day page views for Manny Rutinel: 31,374
30-day page views for Manny Rutinel: 9,879
Rutinel is a Yale Law graduate and former Earthjustice attorney and Army Corps of Engineers economist, first seated in the Colorado House in 2023. At about 30 and the son of a Dominican immigrant single mother, he fits the young, diverse profile of the fast-growing suburban district.
Rutinel won the Democratic primary over former state Rep. Shannon Bird and was placed on the DCCC's Red to Blue list, which channels national money and organizing into the race.
Forecasters rate CO-8 a toss-up and it is the state's most competitive seat. Republican incumbent Gabe Evans won it in 2024 by roughly 49.0%-48.2%, so a well-funded Democrat in a favorable midterm has a real flip opportunity.
Gabe Evans polling: 48%
Gabe Evans polling: 48%
Gabe Evans polling: 48%
Gabe Evans polling: 48%
3-month average US search interest for Gabe Evans: 16/100
3-month average US search interest for Gabe Evans: 3/100
3-month average US search interest for Gabe Evans: 1/100
30-day page views for Gabe Evans: 22,977
30-day page views for Gabe Evans: 20,269
30-day page views for Gabe Evans: 6,687
Evans served as an Army helicopter pilot and later as a police officer in Arvada, giving him firsthand law enforcement and military experience that resonates in a district where public safety is a growing concern.
Evans defeated incumbent Caraveo in 2024 in a race rated as a pure toss-up by every major forecaster, proving he can win in a district that slightly favors Democrats by registration.
Since taking office, Evans has prioritized water infrastructure investment and housing affordability measures for the rapidly growing communities in Adams and Weld counties, key local concerns that cross party lines.
Evans served in the Colorado House of Representatives before his congressional run, working across the aisle on agriculture, water, and rural economic development issues that matter to the exurban portions of CD-8.
Lisa: This is the only real toss-up in Colorado, and Evans only won it by eight-tenths of a point. Rutinel is a Red-to-Blue pick with national money in a D-leaning district. Advantage Democrats.
James: Evans is the incumbent now, and incumbency is worth something even in a swing seat. He's already proven he can win here.
Lisa: He proved he can win by a hair in a presidential year. Midterms with a Republican in the White House flip that math toward the challenger.
James: If the national environment holds. Rutinel is young and relatively new — he has to introduce himself district-wide fast.
Lisa: True, but the DCCC dollars help him do exactly that. Call it lean-Rutinel in a genuine toss-up, re-check with polling.