ClearFactAll topics

Should people support the Second Amendment?

The Second Amendment · 5 peer-reviewed studies for, 6 against

Key takeaways

Stronger evidence: Against

Verdict

Empirical evidence most directly relevant to expansive Second Amendment policy is mixed, but the weight of more recent and methodologically comprehensive work is skeptical that broader public-carry rights reduce violence. Early influential research reported deterrent effects from right-to-carry laws and survey evidence indicates defensive gun use does occur, supporting the intuition that firearms can provide personal protection in some circumstances. However, replication and reanalysis challenged the original deterrence claims, and later comprehensive assessments using longer time horizons and alternative specifications find right-to-carry adoption increases violent crime. This does not settle the constitutional question, but it does weaken the practical argument that expanding gun-carry rights reliably improves public safety. A reasonable policy position could still support limited gun rights paired with stringent training, permitting, safe-storage rules, and strong disqualifier enforcement. But if “support the Second Amendment” is interpreted as endorsing broad deregulation and widespread public carry, the best-available causal evidence points to higher violence risk with unclear offsetting population-level safety benefits. On that interpretation, the stronger side is against.

Strongest study on each side

Ranked by citation count.

Strongest study for

Strongest study against

Open the interactive page →

The evidence

For (5)

To Heller and Back (Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 2009)

David B. Kopel and Paul H. Blackman · 22 citations

Study confirms the Standard Model of the Second Amendment that the Founders intended to recognize and protect an individual right to own and use firearms for self-defense, analyzing legal research and Supreme Court's Heller decision implications.

Against (6)

The Case for Moderate Gun Control (Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 2014)

David DeGrazia · 13 citations

DeGrazia argues that while private gun ownership may be a moral right, the most defensible policy approach features moderate gun control emphasizing safety in home and society, with limitations justified by the rights of those threatened by firearms and empirical evidence about gun-related harms.

Frequently asked questions

Do right-to-carry laws reduce violent crime?

An early study reported reductions in some violent crimes, but reanalysis challenged that finding. A later comprehensive assessment using longer time periods and improved methods found that adopting right-to-carry laws increases violent crime.

How often do people use guns in self-defense?

Estimates differ sharply. One national survey estimated 1 million to 2.5 million defensive gun uses per year, while an analysis of national crime victimization data found self-defense gun use in only 0.9% of incidents.

Is using a gun in self-defense more effective than other ways of resisting?

An analysis of more than 14,000 crime incidents found that self-defense gun use was not more effective than other protective actions at preventing injury or property loss.

Can someone support gun rights and also support gun regulation?

Yes. One ethics argument holds that private gun ownership may be a moral right while moderate gun control is still justified, and a position pairing limited gun rights with training, permitting, safe-storage rules and disqualifier enforcement remains reasonable.

Related questions